♫ It’s the most wonderful time of the year!!! ♫
We’re less than three weeks away from our first NFL regular season Sunday of the 2024 season, and as I like to say, I come bearing a gift. This is my sixth annual Top Players list. Last year’s list was my most descriptive and detailed list yet, with an extra emphasis on player scouting, team schemes and league trends, accompanied by relevant data. This year, in the spirit of what is an ever-evolving and robust world of advanced NFL data and analytics, data is my main theme, as opposed to an ancillary one.
In this piece, my goal was to provide unique and relevant data points that accompany a player, or the team and scheme they play in/for. In here, you’ll find metrics from organizations built on charting data (Pro Football Focus, Sports Info Solutions, FTN Fantasy, Reception Perception), player tracking data (NFL Next Gen Stats), and more (TruMedia, Fantasy Points Data, MatchQuarters, etc).
But I want to give a special shoutout to Field Vision Sports. This organization used cutting-edge algorithms, machine learning and advanced technology to build football’s first predictive analytics app for fans.
In here, you’ll find several accompanying data points from Field Vision, including their proprietary metrics — Havoc Rating and Threat Rating. Each metric was made by creating a model that calculates individual player’s impact on a play-by-play basis based off of recent years of data. Havoc Rates are for defensive players, and Threat Rates are for offensive playmakers. Field Vision Sports‘ app and flagship product launches on September 3rd, and I encourage everyone to follow their social media accounts, sign up for their newsletter and to get the app for your fantasy, betting and overall NFL needs this season. You’ll thank me.
*******
As I say, the goal of this piece is to give readers a comprehensive NFL preseason magazine of sorts, based on players instead of teams. The rankings are tough, and I encourage everyone to critique, but I am really trying to inform NFL fans through data.
But in player placement in these rankings, I try to rank players on how good I think they will be right now, heading into Week 1 of the regular season. In doing that, there’s some forecasting involved. Many NFL players hit a wall at some point in their 30s, and others go from a burgeoning star to an All-Pro in the matter of weeks. It’s impossible to perfectly predict those scenarios, but I think educated guesses can sometimes be accurate. Here, I try my best, and I explain my views with accompanying data.
I have so much fun creating these lists every year. This is the first NFL season I’ll watch that doesn’t include Tom Brady or Bill Belichick. As a Patriots fan who witnessed and cheered for the entire dynasty, things are different now. But football remains the greatest. ❤️ 🏈
Below you can find links to my prior six lists. And with that, let’s get to a few more notes/takeaways, including my Super Bowl 59 pick, and then we’ll get onto the list. Thank you all 🙏
*******
— Unfortunately, injuries happen. They also stink. With the assumption that Christian Barmore will miss some (if not all) time in 2024 with blood clots, I left him off this list after originally having him on. We wish him well in his recovery. The same goes for Matt Milano, who suffered yet another brutal injury recently. Additionally, if I were more sure of their health and play for Week 1, players left off this list that would almost certainly be on it in other circumstances include: Nick Chubb, Jaelen Phillips and T.J. Hockenson. Below is my initial blurb and placement for Barmore before the news of blood clots.
74 |
![]() CHRISTIAN BARMORE
New England · IDL
|
| Barmore is an interior havoc-wrecker who is experiencing exponential growth. I’ve likened his play as a pass-rusher and run stuffer to Chris Jones on multiple occasions, and it seems some in the league are agreeing with me.
“A run-stopper with sack production and big upside,” a NFC scout told ESPN. “Can rush from the inside. Has some Chris Jones to him.” Barmore had 8.5 sacks last year and his 84.9 PFF pass rush grade ranked seventh among interior defensive lineman. During a one-month period between October and early November, only Jones and Aaron Donald notched more pressures than Barmore’s 12, showcasing the level he was playing at. Barmore played in roughly 66% of New England’s defensive snaps last season, leading all Patriots defensive lineman. He could see another uptick in snaps in 2024 as the team further relies on him in early downs as a 4i/5-tech in 3-4 or Nickel 3-3-5 looks, or as a disruptor next to nose tackle Davon Godchaux in 2-4-5 fronts. |
|
— You’ll notice a X, Z or Slot designation next to wide receivers. Many have multiple. This is to give you a clearer picture of what type of receiver you’re reading about. Here is the way I look at it:
X-receiver – Tall, fast, supreme athlete who plays primarily on the outside/boundary and on the line. He is usually a threat going vertical and beating press coverage. (Think: Randy Moss, Calvin Johnson, Julio Jones, D.K. Metcalf, etc.)
Z-receiver – A fast, shifty, versatile route-runner who can play on the perimeter or in the slot, and essentially moves around the formation. Plays on the line or off, and sometimes comes in pre-snap motion. Can be a deep threat or intermediate/underneath high-volume receiver. Comes in all shapes or sizes. (Think: Antonio Brown, Stefon Diggs, Tyler Lockett, Julian Edelman, etc.)
Slot receiver – This receiver used to resemble only a Wes Welker-type as an underneath option route-runner. In the past half-decade or so, this role has evolved as teams put many of their top players in the slot when matchup hunting on third down. But we’ll stick to the receivers who play many/most of their snaps in the slot here. They can be ‘Big’ slots, who win with physicality over the middle (Michael Thomas), speed slots who win on downfield or intermediate routes (CeeDee Lamb), or your classic high-volume slot who wins over the middle with a mix of possession catching, route-running and YAC ability (Amon-Ra St. Brown).
Gadget – Let’s also not forget about your ‘gadget’ type players who can do everything from playing in the Wildcat role, to catching screens, running reverses in pre-snap motion or even just playing plain running back to go along with their receiver duties. (Think: Deebo Samuel, Kadarius Toney, etc.)
—You’ll find two new abbreviated designations this year in IDL (Interior Defensive Lineman) for nose tackles, defensive tackles and 3-4 defensive ends, and SAF for safeties.
— The Eagles and 49ers pace this list yet again when it comes to most players in my Top 101. Last year, Philadelphia (8) led the way with San Francisco (7) behind them. This year, they are switched in placement and number of players on this list. But for my money, the best overall roster is actually in Detroit. The Lions put heavy resources into the boundary cornerback position, helping to solidify their defense. They are a team built in the trenches, with big boy play that gives them a shot versus anyone. And because of that, my Super Bowl 59 pick is the Lions over the Bengals. There’s a bit more worry with Cincinnati, particularly with Joe Burrow’s health and the run defense after losing D.J. Reader to Detroit. But I like the Bengals additions to the offense in the form of tackle play (Amarius Mims should return from injury at some point, Trent Brown) and the skill positions (Zack Moss, Jermaine Burton). Additionally, the signing of safety Geno Stone from division rival Baltimore was a wise one. They needed help at deep safety after losing Jessie Bates to Atlanta.
— Here are the teams with the most players on my list:
San Francisco 49ers (8)
Philadelphia Eagles (7)
Houston Texans (7)
Kansas City Chiefs (6)
Baltimore Ravens (6)
Dallas Cowboys (6)
Detroit Lions (5)
New York Jets (5)
Tampa Bay Buccaneers (4)
Las Vegas Raiders (4)
Cleveland Browns (4)
— Here are the number of players selected for each position:
Quarterback (14)
Running Back (5)
Wide Receiver (19)
Tight End (4)
Tackle (10)
Guard (7)
Center (2)
Interior Defensive Lineman (11)
EDGE (12)
Linebacker (3)
Cornerback (10)
Safety (4)
— Here were the 25 players that nearly made my list, but were squeezed out in the evaluation process:
Cooper Kupp, WR (Slot/Z), Los Angeles Rams
Deebo Samuel, WR (Gadget), San Francisco 49ers
Frankie Luvu, LB, Washington Commanders
Jared Goff, QB, Detroit Lions
Tua Tagovailoa, QB, Miami Dolphins
Keenan Allen, WR (Slot/Z), Los Angeles Chargers
De’Andre Hopkins, WR (X), Tennessee Titans
Breece Hall, RB, New York Jets
Tyron Smith, OT, New York Jets
Joanthan Allen, IDL, Washington Commanders
Terry McLaurin, WR (X), Washington Commanders
Justin Simmons, SAF, Atlanta Falcons
Rashaan Gary, EDGE, Green Bay Packers
DeMarcus Lawrence, EDGE, Dallas Cowboys
David Njoku, TE, Cleveland Browns
Arik Armstead, IDL/EDGE, Jacksonville Jaguars
Alim McNeill, IDL, Detroit Lions
Demario Davis, LB, New Orleans Saints
Lavonte David, LB, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Jaire Alexander, CB, Green Bay Packers
Brian Branch, SAF/CB, Detroit Lions
Jevon Holland, SAF, Miami Dolphins
A.J. Terrell, CB, Atlanta Falcons
Montez Sweat, EDGE, Chicago Bears
Trey McBride, TE, Arizona Cardinals
And now, without further ado, the list…
*******
101 |
![]() DARON BLAND
Dallas · CB
|
| My list begins with one of last year’s top playmakers. Just two seasons after fellow Cowboys teammate Trevon Diggs led the league with 11 interceptions, Daron Bland burst onto the scene with an NFL single-season record five pick-sixes.
The ballhawk cornerback leads the NFL with 14 interceptions over the last two seasons, and last year earned the second-best PFF grade (89.6) among CBs, plus First-team All-Pro honors. Bland’s aggressive, boom-or-bust style is similar to that of Diggs, and the two will start opposite each other on the perimeter in 2024. Dan Quinn had Dallas in a Cover-1/Cover-3-heavy scheme. Bland particularly has fared well in Cover-1. Now under Mike Zimmer, Dallas may still lean on Cover-1, but with more press coverage. Zimmer is known for his ‘Double A-Gap’ blitz package, which should allow for more opportunities for Bland to play the ball on third down passing situations. |
|
100 |
![]() WYATT TELLER
Cleveland · OG
|
| Despite some inconsistent play over the past two seasons, Teller may still be the best overall run-blocking guard in football. He plays with a nice blend of nastiness and athleticism that compliments left guard Joel Bitonio on the other side.
Despite being known for outside zone runs/play-action bootleg passes under head coach Kevin Stefanski, Cleveland ran gap or man rushing concepts on 61.2% of their RB runs last year (3rd in NFL), according to Fantasy Points Data. The downhill concepts suit Teller’s skillset well, but the scheme will be best run if Nick Chubb can regain his health and return to form. One thing to monitor — Cleveland drafted Michigan guard Zak Zinter in the third round of this past NFL Draft. Zinter’s gruesome injury last November and transition to the pros suggest he’ll watch and learn as a rookie, but the Browns could be eyeing him as a long term replacement for Teller as a the physical mauler in the run game. |
|
99 |
![]() BROCK PURDY
San Francisco · QB
|
| Due to the established nature of the 49ers offense prior to his reign as starting QB, Purdy became a polarizing player of sorts last year when it came to assigning praise for San Francisco’s success.
He led the league in Total QBR (72.8), passer rating (113), yards per attempt (9.2) and EPA per play. Typical of a Shanahan-powered offense, Purdy torched defenses in the middle of the field. He led the league in Total EPA versus zone defense, and had the highest yards per attempt mark (12.6) on throws 10-to-19 yards downfield in PFF history (since 2006). That being said, we know San Francisco is a well-oiled and well-constructed machine offensively, equipped with a boatload of unique and versatile playmakers, and led by one of the NFL’s all-time best offensive innovators at head coach. It’s frankly tough to evaluate Purdy’s individual success separate from San Francisco’s perfect scheme. But despite his lesser arm talent and draft status compared to other point-guard contemporaries in Shanahan offenses like Jared Goff and Tua Tagovailoa (and Jimmy Garoppolo before him), Purdy has shown a better knack for improvisation and playmaking out of scheme and structure. According to Field Vision Sports, Purdy when pressured in 2023 ranked first in Total EPA and third in success rate among QBs. He was also PFF‘s top-graded rushing QB, just ahead of Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson. And over the last two seasons, only Patrick Mahomes, Allen and Jackson have graded better out of the pocket, per PFF. Purdy’s second full season under center in this offense should give us more clarity on him as a player. |
|
98 |
![]() D.J. MOORE
Chicago · WR (X/Z)
|
| In Year 1 in Chicago, Moore produced what may have been his best season in the pros (96 catches, 1,364 yards, 8 TDs) in a mostly inefficient offense.
Moore ranked second last year in ESPN Analytics ‘Catch Score’ (93), and NFL Next Gen Stats‘ receptions over expected (+15.1). He’s also a big play threat both after the catch and on vertical concepts, ranking third in EPA produced on ‘Go’ routes in 2023, per Field Vision Sports. He spent roughly 81% percent of his time out wide last season, but he has the ability to play both as a X-receiver, or off-the-line ‘Z’ option. Year 2 will be a lot different for Moore with rookie phenom Caleb Williams at the helm, and Keenan Allen and Rome Odunze on board. Projecting Chicago to have a top-tier receiver trio in 2023 seems like an easy path. Even at his age (32), Allen remains a route-running maestro out of the slot, and Odunze projects as the starting ‘X’ option right out of the gate as a rookie. That should free up Moore’s time to move around the formation. And when combining projection and proven ability in the league, Moore may begin the year as Chicago’s top option until we see otherwise. That may also be evident in his recent mega-contract extension. He’s now the first WR in history to have the first 10 contractual seasons of his career guaranteed. |
|
97 |
![]() KOLTON MILLER
Las Vegas · OT
|
| Even for NFL offensive tackles, Miller stands out as an intimidating force at 6-foot-9, 325 pounds.
Despite the chaotic transition away from Josh McDaniels to an Antonio Pierce-led team during last season, he had a second consecutive solid campaign. He ranks third among left tackles in PFF pass block grade (87.1) over the last four seasons. He also has improved and excelled in run blocking since helping to spring Josh Jacobs to a league rushing title in 2022. Under new offensive coordinator Luke Getsy, we should expect heavy multi-TE sets and outside zone rushing concepts. The Raiders were ninth in zone-rushing rate last season, but ranked 28th in EPA per play when running zone concepts, and fourth in EPA/play in gap/man runs, according to The 33rd Team. |
|
96 |
![]() AMARI COOPER
Cleveland · WR (X)
|
| One of the more underrated/overlooked receivers of the last few years, Cooper put forth maybe his best campaign in his age-29 season with career highs in receiving yards (1,250) and yards per catch (17.4).
He remains the boundary X-receiver tasked with winning versus press coverage, versus man coverage, on the backside of 3×1 alignments, and both out wide or in condensed splits. The X-receiver remains critical to Shanahan/McVay and adjacent offenses. Despite heavy motion and designed passing concepts off of play-action, it’s the backside/on-the-line receiver that can take these offenses to another level (h/t Matt Harmon for explaining this tidbit so well). Cooper ranked second in both yards per reception versus Cover-3 (20.8) and Cover-4/quarters looks (18.8; min. 10 targets) in 2023, according to Fantasy Points Data, making him an ideal option versus modern defensive coverage tendencies. He also led the NFL in receiving yards on pass plays that took longer than three seconds. |
|
95 |
![]() SAQUON BARKLEY
Philadelphia · RB
|
| After a meltdown in the second half of the season offensively last year, the Eagles replaced Brian Johnson with Kellen Moore at offensive coordinator and plucked a prominent name from their NFC East rival in Barkley.
Barkley had his best season since his 2017 rookie campaign in 2022 before the Giants’ morbid offense did him in last year (3.9 yards per carry). The Eagles lost Jason Kelce to retirement but in typical Howie Roseman fashion, they seem to have a plan to cover things up in the trenches with Cam Jurgens moving over from right guard to center and former first-round pick tackle Mekhi Becton signed to play right guard, which should allow them to continue bullying teams on the ground. Philly has leaned heavily on shotgun formations and inside zone rushing concepts over the past few seasons. They were dead last in the NFL in ‘Singleback‘ under-center plays (2%) in 2023, with the NFL average being 20.9%. Kellen Moore’s offenses have ranked 24th, 27th and 22nd in the last three years in shotgun rate, so something has got to give. Moore uses motion and loves to run outside zone under center, but Barkley has had more success in gap runs. In 2022, he had a 54.8% success rate on gap/man runs, and was 36.8% on zone rushing concepts, per Fantasy Points Data. We shouldn’t expect a Christian McCaffrey-to-San Francisco-like production output from Barkley, but I expect he’ll be given a chance to be the bell cow back in Philadelphia with a great season or two left in the tank. “I don’t think you bring in Saquon Barkley unless you plan on him being a foundation piece,” NFL Films guru/analyst Greg Cosell told Inside The Birds podcast. |
|
94 |
![]() VITA VEA
Tampa Bay · IDL
|
| Vea remains one of the more intimidating forces in the NFL that backs up his size and stature with his on-field play.
It’s often hard hard to measure Vea’s importance to Tampa Bay’s defense with data alone. But if you turn on the tape/All-22 film, you’ll see several instances of him bulldozing offensive lineman backwards and blowing up run plays. Tampa was in a 3-4 defense at the fourth-highest rate (34.5%) in the league last year, according to Arjun Menon’s great tool, The Scout. Vea is the nose tackle in a 3-4. But the Buccaneers ‘base’ was a Nickel 2-4-5 look (56.3%) in which Vea is asked to be both a space eater and interior anchor as one of only two down lineman up front. Among his peers last year (0-technique, 1-tech, 2i, 2-tech), Vea led the way with a 12.4% solo tackle rate per run snap on outside/off-tackle gap runs, according to Sports Info Solutions. Further improvement from last year’s first round-pick, Calijah Kancey (6-1, 281 lbs), would help Tampa be more stout and explosive in the interior. Kancey projects as a 5-tech in Tampa’s 3-4 defense and as an interior rusher in 2-down lineman looks. |
|
93 |
![]() KHALIL MACK
L.A. Chargers · EDGE
|
| Mack turned back the clock in his age-32 season, registering 17 sacks (t-4th in NFL), 21 tackles for loss (3rd), 19 run stuffs (1st among EDGE, per NFL Next Gen Stats) and a 90.8 PFF run grade (3rd among EDGE) playing under Brandon Staley’s Vic Fangio-esque defensive system.
Now under Jim Harbaugh, Jesse Minter will be running the show on defense for the Chargers. Minter is a Baltimore Ravens/University of Michigan disciple who will have some crossover elements with Mike Macdonald’s simulated pressures and defensive multiplicity that evolved from Dean Pees’ system, and Rex Ryan before him. This is a different defense schematically than Staley’s, the Chargers will operate out of 3-4 and 2-4-5 looks up front but will be much more aggressive than a Fangio style. Mack expressed his thoughts on Minter’s defense in June: “I feel like everyone plays a 3-4 multiple throughout the league. Exceptions throughout the league…It’s different terms, it’s different techniques that make this defense a little different.” Both Mack and Joey Bosa project well as stand-up EDGE defenders this season, especially if the latter can stay healthy. In terms of depth behind them, there’s Tuli Tuipulotu and Bud Dupree. The latter is strictly a stand-up OLB in 3-4/2-4-5 looks from his time in Pittsburgh and in Tennessee under Pees, giving you a sense of the well-rounded play the system calls for in it’s EDGE defenders. Still, it’s Mack’s ability to pin his ears back and rush the passer that project well for 2024. He tied with Micah Parsons last year for the most QB pressures on 3rd/4th down (41), according to PFF. |
|
92 |
![]() QUENTON NELSON
Indianapolis · OG
|
| 2023 was a bit of a bounce-back campaign for Nelson, who was an All-Pro in each of his first four seasons before an uneven 2022 outing.
He was third among guards in PFF pass block grade (80.3) and his run block win rate (72.4%) ranked near the top at his position. “I thought he was stellar — maybe his best season,” an AFC scout told ESPN. Nelson was insanely hyped as a guard prospect coming into the league. I’ve thought of him as a player with expectations of a near-John Hannah career. If Shane Steichen can fully activate his RPO/inside zone-heavy offense in Year 2 with a healthy Anthony Richardson and Jonathan Taylor, it’ll be Nelson playing an integral part in the trenches up front. The talent is there for him to return to his early-career level of play. |
|
91 |
![]() JONATHAN TAYLOR
Indianapolis · RB
|
| He missed six games in 2022 due to injury and 2023 due to contract dispute (now resolved), but he managed to rush for 487 yards and 6 TDs in his final five games last year, giving a glimpse of what he’s still capable of.
“Still explosive… an AFC scout told ESPN. “The Colts eased him into things. But he’s probably the best combination of size and straight-line speed right now.” As discussed in the Quenton Nelson player blurb above, we should be in for the first full year of Shane Steichen’s designed offensive attack (shotgun-heavy, RPO, inside zone, pistol, pistol play-action, etc.) with both Anthony Richardson and Taylor ready for Week 1 action. |
|
90 |
![]() PUKA NACUA
L.A. Rams · WR (X/Z)
|
| Puka Nacua broke the NFL rookie single-season records for receiving yards (1,486) and receptions (105) last year. Even with the move to a 17-game season (I have a big gripe with ‘records’ and single-season stats due to this), this was one of the most impressive rookie seasons by a receiver that we’ve seen.
Sean McVay came up with several creative ways to utilize Nacua, moving him around the formation and in motion at the snap, and essentially slotting him into the “Cooper Kupp” role while Kupp was away. Even when Kupp returned, it seemed as if he was given a different role (more motion-heavy than usual/slot snaps, etc.), meaning Nacua is likely now the team’s top volume receiver going forward. Nacua played both on and off the line, and had roughly a 70/30 split lining up out wide versus the slot, per PFF. Reception Perception charting had 49.5% of Nacua’s routes as slants, digs or post routes, and NFL Next Gen Stats had him second in receiving yards on in-breaking routes (792). In-breaking routes for receivers off of play-action passing with pre-snap/at-snap motion is a Shanahan/McVay staple. Another staple is condensed formations, where the 49ers and Rams led the league in such snaps and average formation width, per PFF. One major shit in the Rams’ offensive philosophy was the recent veer from outside zone runs/bootleg passing to more power concepts and inside runs. The Rams ranked fourth in the league in man/gap concept usage on RB runs (60.7%) last year, per Fantasy Points Data. They also ranked first in Total EPA and attempts of ‘duo’ and ‘power’ run concepts, per Sports Info Solutions. The Rams often ran duo and other inside runs out of the aforementioned condensed formations, meaning Nacua would be close to the formation with blocking assignments on linebackers, EDGE defenders and D-lineman. Nacua has some size for a receiver (6-2, 212 pounds), and it’s his toughness and scrappiness displayed via his blocking that is an underrated quality, along with his in-game/in-pads tracking speed compared to traditionally-timed results. Nacua had the highest run-blocking grade among WRs last year via PFF. |
|
89 |
![]() BRIAN BURNS
N.Y. Giants · EDGE
|
| Burns is one of the more skilled/athletic pass rushers in the league, exhibiting a nice array of moves (more finesse than power, but packs a mix as a “speed to power” rusher) and production out of different defensive fronts and schemes.
He led the Panthers in overall pressures in each of the last four seasons, according to NFL Next Gen Stats, and he’s combined for 20.5 sacks over the the last two years. He joined the Giants in a tag-and-trade and received a big payday from the G-Men as part of the agreement. “Burns will become Harold Landry in the context of the Giants defense,” NFL Films analyst Greg Cossell says. “He’s {Burns} better than Landry. He’s long, rangy…he’s athletic. He can bend…He’s ‘Gumby’ like, just in the way his body can move.” Thibodeaux, the Giants’ No. 5 overall pick in 2022 will play opposite Burns on the edge. He will probably see more snaps as a down-lineman than Burns. “He can flatten his rush path, which is something Kayvon Thibodeaux can’t do,” says Cossell. “I think he will be a good pro. He’s more of a power player, he’s not a true bender.” It’s Burns who will do the bending on the opposite side. And with superstar nose tackle Dexter Lawrence in the interior, Burns and Thibodeaux will have their chances to garner pressures and sacks. |
|
88 |
![]() ANDREW THOMAS
N.Y. Giants · OT
|
| The former No. 4 overall pick had a career year in 2022, but took a step back in 2023 in year in which the Giants’ were marred by an injury to Daniel Jones and overall offensive disfunction.
Still, Thomas ranked 10th among offensive tackles in PFF pass block grade (80.2) and 11th in pass block win rate (92%). As for Thomas’ play in the run game, he helped spring Saquon Barkley to perhaps his best season two years ago. As explained in Barkley’s player blurb, he was far better in gap/man rushing concepts compared to zone in 2022. And now, Brian Daboll brought in former Patriots and Raiders offensive line coach Carmen Bricillo to signal a further veer toward gap/man concepts typically run by Josh McDaniels (although I expect the Giants to include more shotgun runs than a typical McDaniels offense). “Trent Williams has been the standard, but I think Thomas, if he puts together a stronger body of work, has enough upside to be the top guy,” an AFC executive told ESPN. With Saquon Barkley out of town, and Jones’ future as the team’s starting quarterback beyond 2024 murky, Thomas may be the only true offensive building block for the franchise, unless rookie receiver Malik Nabers (No. 6 overall pick) can join him. |
|
87 |
![]() JAYLON JOHNSON
Chicago · CB
|
| Johnson had a career year in 2023, leading all CBs in PFF coverage grade (91) and in overall play (90.8) while earning Second-team All-Pro honors and a big contract from the Bears.
“Competitive corner with man traits and excellent zone vision,” an NFL personnel evaluator told ESPN. “Physical in press and fluid at the break point. Showed more ball production last year. Only thing he lacks is top-end recovery speed.” Field Vision Sports graded him as the fourth-best cornerback in the NFL in their new metric ‘Havoc Rating.’ which is a 0-100 score that grades a NFL defender’s impact on a play-by-play basis, based on scheme/coverage. Johnson scored a 98.6. He also led the league in forced incompletion percentage. The Bears played 80% of their coverage snaps in zone coverage, per Field Vision Sports, and they grade him as the best zone cover corner in the game. New defensive coordinator Eric Washington comes from the Carolina-Buffalo Sean McDermott tree of zone-heavy principles, which should mesh well with Matt Eberflus’ Cover-3 heavy scheme and Johnson’s play style. |
|
86 |
![]() AARON RODGERS
N.Y. Jets · QB
|
| Rodgers escaped my “let’s see how they fare/if they’re ready for Week 1” post-injury caveat I put into motion for other players such as Nick Chubb, Jaelen Phillips and others that I left off this list considering he’s a quarterback, and that he seems more than ready to go Week 1.
However, his age (40) and predicting how he’ll fear post-Achilles injury make this a tough projection. As it stands, I didn’t think he looked right in his pocket movement in the few plays leading up to the injury last year, as silly as that sounds. Adding to that his decline in 2022 after back-to-back MVP seasons before that, and it’s worth wondering how much he has left. But I like what the Jets have done in bolstering their offensive line this offseason. They added more than capable starters at tackle in veterans Tyron Smith (All-Pro in 2023, but aging) and Morgan Moses, and drafted stud prospect Olu Fashanu at No. 9 overall. They also brought in another Ravens offensive lineman in guard John Simpson. Rodgers has the second-best total QBR when not under pressure since 2021 (79.1). He has a bonafide WR1 waiting to happen in Garrett Wilson, Breece Hall as a potential star at running back, Malachi Corley in place as a rookie replacement in the Randall Cobb role, and old buddy Nathaniel Hackett at offensive coordinator. The days of top-end quarterback play for him may be over, but I think he’ll sit somewhere in between that and 2015 Peyton Manning. He’s still one of the game’s best throwers of the football. The question is his mobility. I think the AFC East is ripe for the taking for the Jets roster. Can Rodgers help lead them to a division title? |
|
85 |
![]() RASHAWN SLATER
L.A. Chargers · OT
|
| He lacks the length of your typical NFL offensive tackle, but he’s already proven himself in the league, particularly with a mess surrounding him on the line.
He was PFF‘s fifth-highest graded tackle in pass coverage last year, and now he’ll get to put his play strength to more use under new head coach Jim Harbaugh and offensive coordinator Greg Roman, where the Chargers will look to establish a power-running identity. Slater, coming from Northwestern, is certainly familiar with Harbaugh and Big Ten bully ball. He’ll play opposite No. 5 overall pick rookie Joe Alt to help protect Justin Herbert and spring open rushing lanes for ex-Ravens RBs Gus Edwards and J.K. Dobbins. To me, the Chargers are one of the more fascinating teams in 2024. |
|
84 |
![]() JALEN RAMSEY
Miami · CB
|
| Ramsey tore his meniscus in training camp last season and then returned in time to play 1o games. His play predictably suffered.
Part of that could be the failed experiment of the Vic Fangio experience defensively in Miami. After finding success in the “Star” position in the Rams’ defense, and spending some time in that role in 2022 in Miami, Ramsey played just 15 snaps in the slot last season. The Dolphins brought in Anthony Weaver from Baltimore to run the defense, and it’s worth noting whether or not Ramsey may see a return to the slot. Miami picked up cornerback Kendall Fuller, who can play on the outside. Safety Jevon Holland is also an emerging star. Miami will need all the help they can get from their secondary with what may be a subpar pass rush with Christian Wilkins gone, Jaelan Phillips returning from injury and Bradley Chubb on the PUP list. Weaver will likely lean on simulated pressures and hope for quick learning out of rookie first-round pick Chop Robinson on the edge. |
|
83 |
![]() DEVON WITHERSPOON
Seattle · CB
|
| Witherspoon had a fine rookie campaign, grading out as the league’s sixth best cornerback according to PFF (2nd among CBs in pass rush grade), and earning four first-place Defensive Rookie of The Year votes.
He played only 229 total snaps in the slot in college before playing 355 snaps there in coverage alone last year in Seattle. He spent 46% of his snaps in the slot, and could project there in Mike Macdonald’s Nickel 2-4-5 (3-4 principles) base scheme. Witherspoon doesn’t have the advanced versatility, size or all-world skillset of Ravens’ do-it-all nickel Kyle Hamilton, but he’s capable of doing the dirty work necessary for the slot defender position, while also guarding all types of receivers in coverage. “Witherspoon is a baller,” an AFC scout told ESPN. “He’s the most physical corner in the NFL, and he’s hyper competitive.” According to Field Vision Sports‘ new metric ‘Havoc Rating,’ Witherspoon was the third-best pass-rushing cornerback, seventh-best run defender, and 10th best overall at his position. His versatility should allow the Seahawks to prioritize Tariq Woolen on select receiver matchups, while Witherspoon moves around the defense. |
|
82 |
![]() KOBIE TURNER
L.A. Rams · IDL
|
| After years of trading their first-round picks for established talent to go “all-in” each season, the Rams finally began thinking of the future and prioritizing the draft in 2023. They selected 14 players between Rounds 2 and 7 last year, which included a few major hits like Puka Nacua and Kobie Turner.
Playing next to Aaron Donald in the Rams’ 3-4 defensive scheme, Turner notched nine sacks as a rookie and had the league’s best PFF pass grade from Week 11 on (90.3). His production came versus a 72% double team rate on pass-rush downs, which tied Chris Jones for the highest such rate among the Top 20 pass-rush win rate leaders in the interior. He was a master of garnering quick pressures versus centers and guards. With Raheem Morris now in Atlanta, Chris Shula (grandson of Don) takes over as defensive coordinator, but the Rams are expected to continue leaning on a mix of Nickel/Big Nickel 2-4-5 (25.9% of defensive snaps in 2023) and and 3-3-5 looks (30.2%). The rams selected stand-up EDGE Jared Verse and defensive tackle/5-tech Braden Fiske in Rounds 1 and 2 of the draft to plug in up front, but with Donald retired, there’s more pressure on Turner to carry the torch as an interior disruptor up front, which has become an increasingly important role in today’s game, especially with the Rams leading the league in two-high safety snaps last year (per The Athletic Football Show). |
|
81 |
![]() KYLER MURRAY
Arizona · QB
|
| The rebuilding Cardinals were a spunky bunch last year, playing well beyond what was predicted of them from a talent and scheme implementation timeline both offensively and defensively.
In Year 2 under head coach Jonathan Gannon and offensive coordinator Drew Petzing, the Cardinals should again lean on the running game out of multi-tight end sets both in shotgun and under-center. The Cardinals led the league in 13 personnel rate (1 RB, 3 TE) last year at 10.1%, and they also ran a healthy amount of 12 personnel. They led the league in explosive rushing rate, according to RBSDM, and Post-Week 10 (Kyler Murray’s return), Arizona led the NFL in rushing yards per attempt (5.3) and EPA/attempt. Everything is on the menu for Murray in 2024, which should include a larger shift to play-action passes under center and shotgun zone-read rushes, which is a healthy mix of Nick Sirianni Eagles and Kevin Stefanski Browns/Vikings concepts represented by Gannon and Petzing. Third-round draft pick Trey Benson is a bigger back that represents the Cardinals’ overall shift to power running under the new regime. In the passing game, Murray now has Marvin Harrison Jr. at the X-receiver spot, with Trey McBride as a burgeoning top-tier “flex” TE and Michael Wilson as a reliable possession receiver. There are pieces in place for Arizona to make a surprising run at a NFC wild card spot, but the operation will go as far as Murray takes the. |
|
80 |
![]() DERRICK HENRY
Baltimore · RB
|
| Henry landing in Baltimore is fascinating. One of the best power runners in NFL history joins one of the more unique successful rushing attacks we’ve ever seen.
The Ravens shifted from Greg Roman’s condensed formations to Todd Monken’s spread looks last year. Baltimore saw a huge increase in 11 personnel usage from 2022 (12.2%) to 2023 (46.2%), although part of that was due to Mark Andrews’ injury. Baltimore is mostly looking to spread teams out in shotgun now. In the last four years, only 19.7% of Henry’s rush attempts have come out of shotgun, but he ranks second in EPA per shotgun rush among RBs during that span. Baltimore also was sixth in pistol formation snaps (8.3%), meaning they could replicate some of the under-center runs/play-action passes from Henry’s time in Tennessee. Henry should get some looks versus lighter boxes, something he rarely saw last year in Tennessee. 53.5% of his first-down runs last year came with eight or more defenders in the box, which led the league. Still, “King Henry” once again paced the NFL in yards after contact (619), and rushed for 1,167 rushing yards and 12 touchdowns. “He’s a warrior,” a veteran NFL coach told ESPN. “Just keeps himself in such good physical conditioning with offseason workouts. I don’t see him slowing down over the next two years. He’s a volume back with great size, breaks tackles, has deceptive speed and no one’s really catching him if he gets going. I don’t think he’s lost a step.” There’s some valid concern regarding his age (30) and the fact that he’s led the league in carries in four out of the last five seasons, including last year. But Baltimore is a savvy operation, and it’s hard not to get excited about Lamar Jackson-Derrick Henry zone reads, or Henry running behind bruising fullback/H-back Pat Ricard. |
|
79 |
![]() CHRIS OLAVE
New Orleans · WR (Z)
|
| Olave is a smooth-running receiver who is a vertical threat from the slot while also packing diverse route-running ability on the outside.
His average depth of target from the slot (12.8 yards) led all pass catchers in 2023, while he still spent roughly 62% of his time on the outside. He’s essentially the Z-receiver, or “flanker” of the offense with 69.6% of his sampled snaps in 2023 coming off the line, per Reception Perception. Klint Kubiak is the new offensive coordinator for the Saints, meaning elements of the Shanahan offense may find their way to New Orleans. Olave can work off of wide-zone/bootleg play-action concepts on designed deep shots and intermediate routes. He’s New Orleans’ clear option at WR1, with Rashid Shaheed as the only encouraging option after him on the WR depth chart. The play of Derek Carr (or Spencer Rattler) at QB and the offensive line will factor in mightily this year. |
|
78 |
![]() STEFON DIGGS
Houston · WR (Z/Slot)
|
| Diggs led the NFL in receptions (445) during his four-year stint in Buffalo, and he led the league in tight-window receptions (17) last season. However, his numbers and play tapered off a bit, specifically toward the end of year, and now he heads to a new team for his age-30 season.
“I saw a little decline — I think his vertical speed has tapered off a bit,” an AFC exec said to ESPN. I expect a rejuvenated and more explosive version of Diggs, at least for one more season, now that he has a fresh start in Houston. Nico Collins (who is on this list) is Diggs’ challenger for WR1 duties. Of course, this shouldn’t be seen as a “challenge” as the two should co-exist in harmony, but we know Diggs is more prone to emotional behavior if not a game plan focal point. Collins is the surefire X-receiver in this offense, so Z-receiver and slot duties will likely be split by Diggs and Tank Dell. Dell is a vertical threat due to speed and not size, and would appear to be a vertical slot option, but he spent 75% of his snaps out wide, per PFF. Diggs spent 54% of Reception Perception‘s sampled snaps off the line, and 36% in the slot. He will be a Z/slot hybrid. A moveable receiver with top-tier route-running skills. Reception Perception also charted 48% of Diggs sampled snaps as a slant, curl or screen route. I expect that to change dramatically in Houston, where C.J. Stroud had the second-highest average depth of target among qualified passers last season. |
|
77 |
![]() JORDAN LOVE
Green Bay · QB
|
| Only Dak Prescott (36) threw more touchdowns than Jordan Love (32) last season as the young Packers QB led Green Bay to playoffs, where they upset Dallas and nearly took down San Francisco after.
There were some concerns over his play earlier in the year, but he was magnificent down the stretch. In a nine-game period that included his final eight regular season contests and the wild card win over Dallas, Love totaled 21 TDs and just one interception with a 135.6 passer rating. From Week 11 on he led the NFL in EPA/attempt. Love also had a 70.5 QBR inside the pocket and ranked third among QBs in QBR under pressure. Green Bay recently awarded him a contract extension that could suggest he’ll be quarterbacking in Lambeau Field for a long time, continuing after Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers before him. He’s a talented passer with the arm strength and ball placement to succeed in Matt Lafluer’s Shanahan/McVay-style system that helped Aaron Rodgers win back-to-back NFL MVP awards in 2020 and 2021. Love is also a solid off-platform passer, giving him a Rodgers or Matthew Stafford-lite ability to be a playmaker on crucial downs. Despite no emerging star receiving option, there’s a plethora of young talent at WR and TE for Love to work with. And with Josh Jacobs and A.J. Dillon now the top rushing options, LaFluer may look to attack defenses with more inside runs like his past mentors in San Francisco and Los Angeles. The Rams’ offense in particular with Matthew Stafford would replicate well with Jordan Love both executing under-center play-action passes in 11 personnel and drop-back passing out of shotgun on money downs. That’s essentially what they were veering to already. |
|
76 |
![]() JALEN HURTS
Philadelphia · QB
|
| The Eagles fell apart in the second half of the season, with Hurts experiencing a setback performance after his near-MVP campaign in 2022.
He ran for a career-high 15 touchdowns and still ranked eighth among QBs in PFF pass grade, run grade and overall play, but his interception total went from six in 2022 to 15 last season, and a year after losing zero fumbles, he lost four. “I spoke to coaches who were on the Eagles staff. The biggest challenge you are going to face with Hurts is his expansive ability to be able to be a full field player,” Greg Cossel told Inside The Birds. “The year they made the Super Bowl, in the middle of the season they cut their offense down because he is not a full field reader.” Hurts is not the game’s best multi-read, full-field dropback passer, but he’s a uniquely gifted dual threat at quarterback as a power runner on zone-read attempts and inside runs. The Eagles led the league in shotgun rate on first down (70%) in 2023, and spent roughly 95% of their plays in shotgun, pistol or empty looks. New offensive coordinator Kellen Moore’s offenses have ranked 24th, 27th and 22nd in shotgun rate over the last few seasons. “He is very multiple, you are going to see a lot of different personnel packages,” says Cossel. “He {Kellen Moore} is a believer in motion so we are going to see how that all plays out. This is going to be a different looking offense…if you start using a lot of motion, what it does is shrink the menu for the defense. The addition of Moore, running back Saquon Barkley, and Hurts’ ability to play under-center/in pistol formation are storylines that will define the Eagles offense, along with their ability to replace Jason Kelce at center. |
|
75 |
![]() JOEL BITONIO
Cleveland · OG
|
| This was the only time in the last six years that Bitonio was not named named an AP First-team or Second-team All-Pro. Yet, he ranked sixth among interior offensive lineman in pass block win rate (96%) and his run block win rate (72%) was also solid.
Entering his age-33 season, he remains one of the league’s best pass-blocking guards. “Still playing at a very high level — age showing a bit in pass protection but one of the most reliable guards of the last decade,” an AFC executive said to ESPN. “He could be a sneaky Hall of Famer when it’s all said and done.” Like other similarly-constructed running games around the league, the Browns shifted from zone-rushing concepts to a heavy dose of gap and man runs in 2023 (see: Wyatt Teller’s player blurb above). |
|
74 |
![]() CHARVARIUS WARD
San Francisco · CB
|
| Putting my data theme to use here with a data darling who has spent his six seasons in the league with arguably the two most successful teams during that span (Chiefs, 49ers).
Ward was named Second-team All-Pro last year after a career-high five interceptions and league-leading 23 passes defended. A year after he was the sixth-highest graded CB by PFF, he graded out as the fifth, and ranked third in coverage grade. “Probably the most underrated corner in the league,” and NFC coordinator said to ESPN. “Doesn’t get a lot of credit, but he’s a problem for the top receivers.” Field Vision Sports‘ new propriety metric, ‘Havoc Rating‘, is a 0-100 score that grades a NFL defender’s impact on a play-by-play basis, based on scheme/coverage. Ward was their top-graded cornerback with a Havoc Rating of 100. He was their top-ranked CB in zone coverage, as well, and he was the only player at his position to grade in the Top-5 in Havoc Rating in man and zone coverage. The 49ers are primarily a Cover-4/quarters and Cover-3 defense. San Francisco ran Cover-3 or Cover-4 on a combined 59% of defensive snaps last season. Ward (6-1, 196 pounds) is a lengthy cornerback who is perfect for that skillset. He spends almost all of his time on the boundary. He spent 1,042 snaps outside in 2023, and 17 in the slot, per PFF. |
|
73 |
![]() MIKE EVANS
Tampa Bay · WR (X)
|
| Evans has played 10 seasons and is still just 30 years old entering 2024.
He’s broken the 1,000-yard mark in all 10 campaigns. He’s also caught 12 or more touchdowns in five of 10 seasons (13 in 2023) and has eclipsed the 14 yards per reception mark in every year other than 2016 (15.9 last season). The future Hall-of-Famer should be regarded as one of the best boundary/vertical X-receivers of his era, and judging by last season, he still has the juice to win 1-on-1 matchups on the outside for Baker Mayfield in Year 2 in Tampa. I’m not ready to predict a cliff-like regression for Evans yet, even if I’m weary of labeling him a top-10 receiver heading into this year. As for the rest of the Bucs’ receiving core, Chris Godwin is projected to spend more time back in the slot this season, and rookie third-round pick Jalen McMillan projects as a versatile option to round out the 11 personnel WR trio. “He {McMillan} had a lot of versatility in college,” says Tampa Bay head coach Todd Bowles. “He played slot, he played Z, he played X, so he’s a very intelligent player, so that gives us some advantages.” |
|
72 |
![]() DEREK STINGLEY JR.
Houston · CB
|
| Year 2 for Stingley was much more in line with a former No. 3 overall pick’s progression as a pro. He notched five interceptions, ranked fifth in PFF coverage grade among CBs (85.3) and led the NFL in ball-hawk rate (31%).
“So smooth and athletic,” an AFC scout said to ESPN. “No physical limitations. Really strong with good ball skills.” Head coach DeMeco Ryans is attempting to run his defense like he did in San Francisco, where the unit is predicated on pass rush from their four-down front, speed in the front seven, and Cover-3 and Cover-4/quarters looks in the back end. Stingley has potential elite man coverage chops necessary on third down and versus top-end receivers. But his size (6-foot, 190 lbs) and ballhawk/closing ability make him a good fit in this system. He’d be a good fit in any scheme, and his best days are ahead of him. |
|
71 |
![]() QUINCY WILLIAMS
N.Y. Jets · LB
|
| Williams earned First-team All-Pro honors last year and graded second by PFF among linebackers in pass coverage.
We wouldn’t dare compare him to Fred Warner, but his style of play is what’s necessary from linebackers in Robert Saleh’s scheme. Williams is an explosive player who roams sideline-to-sideline and likes to hit. He’s a perfect “roamer” next to C.J. Mosley, who was also athletic/fast back in the day, but now at age 32 is playing more of that old-school/calculated, high-IQ linebacker type that you’d expect as an alumni of Nick Saban’s Alabama and the Baltimore Ravens. |
|
70 |
![]() TREY HENDRICKSON
Cincinnati · EDGE
|
| “Underrated” is mostly a cliche term at this point, which is why I try to use the word sparingly in this exercise. I bring the moniker up here for just the second time (after Amari Cooper) because I truly think it fits here.
“Not sure why he doesn’t get more love — very productive rusher, a pain to play against and a good run player,” an NFC executive told ESPN. Hendrickson plays on the edge in the Bengals 4-2-5 scheme. He tied for second in the league last year with 17.5 sacks. His 40.5 sacks since 2021 rank fifth in the league. He initially asked for a trade earlier this offseason, as he’s looking for a new deal. |
|
69 |
![]() GARRETT WILSON
N.Y. Jets · WR (X)
|
| Wilson has powered through one of the league’s very worst quarterback situations over the last two years to put up two productive seasons to kick off his NFL career.
He was fifth among all pass catchers in ESPN‘s ‘Open Score‘, and Reception Perception put him in the 96th percentile among WRs in man coverage success rate, and in the 93rd percentile versus press. He can move inside when necessary but primarily has the X-receiver role in the Jets offense. He could see more time at the Z-receiver spot off the line with Mike Williams now in the lineup. I’m repeating what I said in last year’s list only because it’s one of my favorite quirky scouting notes. I think Wilson moves like “Spiderman” with his violent cuts/moves whether it be in his route-running, at the catch point or after the catch. He was second only to Deebo Samuel in broken tackles by a WR with 22 last year. He’s a do-it-all threat that should jump a tier, and many spots on this list, after a season with competent quarterback play. |
|
68 |
![]() JUSTIN MADUBUIKE
Baltimore · IDL
|
| Madubuike earned a hefty contract extension in the offseason after an All-Pro season (Second-team) in which he notched 13 sacks and 77 total pressures (3rd among IDL, via PFF).
“Disruptive in both phases, but power was his most improved tool [in 2023],” an AFC executive said to ESPN. The Ravens are a 3-4 principled defense who led the NFL in Nickel/Big Nickel 2-4-5 snaps in 2023 (72.8%). Madubuike has spent time as a 4i/5-tech but works heavily as a 3-tech, an alignment where he led the league in pressures in 2023, per NFL Next Gen Stats. With two-gapping nose tackle types often playing next to him (Michael Pierce, Travis Jones, etc.), Madubuike is a nice compliment as an emerging pass-rushing star you are starting to see around the league in the interior. |
|
67 |
![]() SAM LAPORTA
Detroit · TE
|
| Laporta “Kool-Aid” man-ed his way into the league with 10 touchdowns and Second-team All-Pro honors as a rookie. The 2023 draft saw nine tight ends selected in the first three rounds (five in Round 2), and Detroit selected the class front runner at pick 34.
“He’s f—ing awesome,” a veteran NFC scout told ESPN. “Everything looks super easy and natural to him. Great feet. Great in the red zone. Strains every play, whether blocking or running routes. Plays the game the right way, snap in and snap out. Strong for his size and so instinctive.” According to NFL Next Gen Stats, Laporta led all TEs in receiving EPA in the middle of the field. He operates mostly in-line but is an explosive receiver to the point where he had 432 snaps in the slot or out wide, which feels very Gronk-ish. Laporta led all TEs in routes run and TDs (4) from an outside alignment. He’s a key piece of the Lions’ offense as a Y-TE who moves well after the catch and breaks tackles like a man possessed. |
|
66 |
![]() DEVONTA SMITH
Philadelphia · WR (Z/X)
|
| The former Heisman Trophy winner is a route-running aficionado who makes up for his smaller frame (170 pounds) with outstanding nuance both at the top of his route and while initially beating press coverage.
Smith has caught has +25.9 receptions over expected in his three seasons in the NFL, per NFL Next Gen Stats, which is second-most behind just Justin Jefferson. He earned a contract extension in Philadelphia in April. Despite having the body type and several attributes of a Z-receiver, the Eagles obviously feel comfortable with his ability on the line. Reception Perception charted him taking just 38.2% of his snaps off the line in 2023. They also have him above the 80th percentile in success rate versus press coverage in all three of his seasons, and as a fantastic winner on several route concepts such as such as digs, posts, curls comebacks and slants. Smith actually spent slightly more time on the outside and less in the slot than teammate A.J. Brown last season. With Kellen Moore now in the fold, you can expect Smith to spend more time in the slot and flanker spots. There’s already reports of him spending more time in the slot at training camp. Moore likes to lean on 11 personnel and also may have to replicate some of his under-center play-action passing concepts out of pistol looks for Jalen Hurts. |
|
65 |
![]() DEFOREST BUCKNER
Indianapolis · IDL
|
| Buckner remains a force both in the middle and lined up over tackles as a 5-tech on the Colts defensive line.
The 6-foot-7, 295-pound defender has been double teamed at one of the highest rates in the league over the past seven seasons, and he was doubled on 66% of pass rush snaps in 2023. Despite that, he ranked fifth among interior defensive lineman in pass rush win rate (17%) and fourth in PFF pass rush grade (87.1). He also was tied for third among IDL in third-down pressures (27), via Sports Info Solutions. Buckner has also notched at least seven sacks in every season since 2018, including an 8-sack campaign last year. Additionally, he had 56 defensive stops last season, third among his position, per NFL Next Gen Stats. “Consistent. Really productive. Plays with the best motor of any of the D-linemen, ” an NFL scouting director said to ESPN. Field Vision Sports projects Buckner as its No. 1 interior defender in 2024 Havoc Rating, and he was second in the NFL in raw Havoc Rating in 2023. |
|
64 |
![]() DERRICK BROWN
Carolina · IDL
|
| Brown may be the best run-stopping defender in the entire league. Sitting at 6-5, 320 pounds, he mostly lines up as a 4i/5-technique or B-gap defender in the Panthers 3-4-style defense with both Nickel 3-3-5 and 2-4-5 tendencies.
He’s been PFF‘s best run defender over the last two seasons with a 90.1 run grade, and he led the NFL last year with a 47.1 % run stop win rate. His 79 defensive stops also led all interior defenders by 10, per NFL Next Gen Stats. Additionally, he topped Field Vision Sports‘ raw Havoc run-stopping score list for his position by a wide margin, and he was second overall in Havoc Rating among interior defensive lineman. He’s improved mightily as a push-the-pocket pass rusher. His 16 pressures from a nose tackle alignment ranked second in the league last season, according to PFF. |
|
63 |
![]() MINKAH FITZPATRICK
Pittsburgh · SAF
|
| Fitzpatrick suffered a bit of a down season in 2023, falling from third to 20th in PFF safety grade and notching zero interceptions. Along with missing seven games due to injury, part of the reason for his off year could be the way he was deployed by Pittsburgh.
“He was playing closer to the line of scrimmage this year — not sure why, maybe they needed his leadership and instincts up there, but it hurt his bottom line,” an NFL personnel evaluator told ESPN. According to ESPN Stats and Info, Minkah spent just 51% of his snaps as a free safety in 2023 after being lined up there 76% of the time in 2022. He spent 30% of his time in the box last year. “The biggest thing is as coaches, our job is to try to get all of our guys in the best position as possible so they can play as well as they can and play up to their abilities,” Pittsburgh defensive coordinator Teryl Austin said to ESPN. “And so last year I probably failed in that regard. We tried to have him {Fitzpatrick} do too much stuff, and I think I’m going to get back to really what makes him special.” Fitzpatrick is versatile enough to play anywhere, which I stressed in last year’s list. That’s part of why he was viewed as the NFL’s best safety prior to 2023 after leading the league in interceptions and ball hawk rate the year before. He was named a First-team All-Pro three times in four seasons prior to this year. He should be moved around. Post safety, in the slot, in the box, and deep. But he’s best served as a roaming playmaker while others stay in more defined roles. Pittsburgh has leaned on three-safety packages over the last few seasons. This year in those looks you can expect Damontae Kazee to continue playing deep, while newcomer DeShon Elliott plays more in the box as a thumper of sorts in the run game. That should allow Minkah to move around a bit more when necessary, and perhaps get back to more second-level diagnosing in pass defense rather than extra reps in run defense or blitzing the QB from the slot (things he’s still also good at, mind you). “Just let me play ball — Minkah Ball,” Fitzpatrick said to ESPN. “We’ve got to look at the ’22 tape and see what we did there.” |
|
62 |
![]() L’JARIUS SNEED
Tennessee· CB
|
| Sneed is an all-around cornerback who can play on the boundary or in the slot. He can blitz, defend the run, and guard some of the game’s best receivers, which he did in 2023 en route to his second Super Bowl ring.
His coverage matchup assignments were often arguably harder than teammate Trent McDuffie’s. McDuffie took Sneed’s old role in the slot. Sneed had 592 snaps in the slot (reg + postseason) in 2022 before just 29 reps there last season, where he spent most of his time on the outside (1,142 snaps). Some of his advanced analytics and PFF grading took a hit, and he led the NFL in penalties (17), but he didn’t allow a touchdown all season. “…With the bigger body receivers, he can dominate as a physical press corner because of his physicality, and he’s always up for the challenge,” an AFC defensive coach told ESPN. “Excels in man or zone. And he has a knack for timely playmaking, and he will come up in run support and tackle.” Field Vision Sports ranked Sneed as its second-best zone coverage CB mostly due to his press coverage skills and ability to play different coverages. Sneed also had the second-highest Havoc Rating (99.1) among his peers. Sneed earned a big deal in Tennessee this offseason, where he’ll likely continue to play on the boundary with Roger McCreary penciled into their slot/nickel role. |
|
61 |
![]() JESSIE BATES
Atlanta · SAF
|
| Bates proved to be one of the rare big free agent acquisition hits last year. He was named Second-team All-Pro for the second time, with a litany of stats to prove his worth and well-rounded game.
He led all safeties in ‘ball hawk rate’ (28.2%), was second among his position in solo and total tackles, third in interceptions (6), and PFF graded him in the top three at his position in coverage, run defense and overall play. Bates also posted the second-highest ‘Havoc Rating‘ among safeties. Field Vision Sports created the metric to calculate a NFL defender’s impact on a play-by-play basis, based off of years of defensive play-by-play data and accounting for the scheme that player plays in. Bates moves around the backend and up in the box some but is primarily a deep/free safety. “He’s been one of the more consistent safeties in the league for a long time now,” an AFC executive said to ESPN. Former University of Washington head coach Jimmy Lake was brought over from the Rams by Raheem Morris to run the Falcons’ defense. Bates may play multiple spots in 2024. “It will be a base 3-4 for sure, but very multiple as soon as teams go 11 or less personnel,” said Lake in February about his proposed scheme. “You could see us in a lot of different fronts with various coverages, and we’re going to lean on all of our experience that we’ve had over the years and also some of the stuff that the 2023 defense did here as well.” |
|
60 |
![]() DANIELLE HUNTER
Houston · EDGE
|
| Hunter found a home in Houston this offseason opposite young phenom Will Anderson on the opposite edge.
Last season he tied for the league-lead in tackles for loss (23) and was fifth in sacks (16.5). He has five seasons of double digit sacks and three with 14.5 or more. He’s still under the age of 30 and remains one of the more explosive pass rushers in the league. Although he hasn’t generally been considered a great run defender compared to other Tier 1 or 2 EDGE defenders, Field Vision Sports‘ Havoc Rating had him seventh at his position versus the run last year. But it’s mostly his ability to pin his ears back and attack the quarterback in DeMeco Ryans’ four-down front defense that separates him from others at his position. His pass rush Havoc Rating was second among EDGE defenders in 2023. “Hunter is long, athletic, bendy” says NFL Films analyst Greg Cossel via The Xs and Os podcast with himself and Doug Farrar. “He’s a disruptive player.” |
|
59 |
![]() CHRISTIAN WILKINS
Las Vegas · IDL
|
| Wilkins earned a mega deal in Las Vegas this offseason, where he’ll look to create disruption in the interior with Maxx Crosby on the outside.
PFF has him as the fourth-highest graded interior defender in run defense over the last two seasons, and he was third among his position in pressures last year, per ESPN. He was double-teamed at a high rate last season (65% of snaps), but still he had a solid year. The Raiders defensively ran a 4-2-5 front at the second-highest clip (77.8%) last year via Arjun Menon’s The Scout. Wilkins can play the disruptor role next to nose tackle John Jenkins. He can also occupy multiple gaps in run defense. He gives Las Vegas a chance to become more versatile in their alignments and personnel up front. |
|
58 |
![]() JEFFERY SIMMONS
Tennessee · IDL
|
| He missed five games last year due to injury after two All-Pro seasons (Second-team) in the campaigns before. He played a heavy mix of 3-tech and 5-tech in Mike Vrabel’s scheme, and is a solid fit for defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson, who comes over from Baltimore.
“When he’s focused and sets out to make a lot of plays, he’s pretty much unblockable,” a head scout with an NFL team said to ESPN. “I think he’ll have a big year, similar to [Justin] Madubuike in that same Baltimore scheme last year.” Simmons’ play will carry over from one scheme’s multiple-front attack plan to another. Baltimore led the league in 2-4-5 fronts last year (72.8%), per Arjun Menon’s The Scout, and they’re rooted in mostly 3-4 principles. Simmons has the power to play nose tackle or 5-tech in an early-down 3-4 defense, but rookie nose tackle T’Vondre Sweat (6-4, 366 pounds) from Texas is expected to play farthest inside. The two together in 2-4-5 fronts could wreck run-heavy game plans in 2024. |
|
57 |
![]() BIJAN ROBINSON
Atlanta · RB
|
| A word of advice — draft Bijan Robinson in fantasy football this season if you get the chance.
Here I put the “30% of brainpower toward potential production” rule to use as Robinson had just 976 yards and 4 TDs on the ground last year in Arthur Smith’s multi-back attack with Robinson (214 carries), Tyler Allgeier (186) and even Cordarrelle Patterson (50). However, Robinson averaged 4.6 yards per carry (5.2 YPC in stacked boxes) and was tied for fourth with seven 20-yard+ rushes last year, and he should be the bell cow back in a dynamic rushing scheme under offensive coordinator Zac Robinson, who left McVay’s Rams for this role. As explained in Puka Nacua’s blurb, the Rams shifted from outside zone to inside runs last year, running duo at the highest rate and leading the NFL in Total EPA in the concept, per Sports Info Solutions. Bijan was second in the nation among all college RBs in total EPA on duo runs in 2022 at Texas. The Falcons were dead last in duo attempts last year, but still ranked third in total EPA on the concept with Robinson as the lead back. In addition to the favorable scheme and run concepts tailored to him, Robinson will play behind one of the league’s better offensive lines and should still be used as a weapon in the passing game after he showed some flashes in that area last year. |
|
56 |
![]() JALEN CARTER
Philadelphia · IDL
|
| Carter showed extended stretches of brilliance in his rookie season. Through Week 8, he was second among interior defenders in PFF grade (91.6), and although his play tailed off toward the second half, he still finished sixth among his peers in PFF grade (87.4) and pass rush win rate (16%).
“Extremely explosive and tremendous upside if he can keep his head on straight and just stay in shape, and AFC executive told ESPN. “He was beating All-Pro guards when he was fresh.” Vic Fangio is taking over the Eagles defense in 2024, where he’ll bring his 3-4 principled 2-4-5 looks to Philly. Fangio’s two-high safety, gap-and-a-half defense has spread across the league. What you’ll notice with all of these defensive lines is that they have difference of style in their interior defenders, especially in a 2-4-5. Like Jeffery Simmons and T’Vondre Sweat in the blurb above, the Eagles already have a space-eating nose tackle (Jordan Davis) and then their overall disruptor in Carter, who is the more well-rounded force in the middle who can rush the passer and overall create havoc in the middle. As the Fletcher Cox era closes, the Carter era begins. He is a star in the making. |
|
55 |
![]() WILL ANDERSON JR.
Houston · EDGE
|
| Concluding the trio of second-year, all-world potential candidates here after Bijan Robinson and Jalen Carter with last year’s Defensive Rookie of the Year.
Anderson ranked second among EDGE defenders in run stop win rate (35%) and third in pass rush win rate (26%) in 2023. PFF charted Anderson with the best pressure rate (16.7%) among rookie EDGE defenders in the past four seasons. “Wins with power, instincts and motor, not raw athleticism. Really good first year for him,” an AFC executive said to ESPN. Between Derek Stingley Jr., C.J. Stroud and Laremy Tunsil, the Texans have blue-chip talents that appear to be franchise cornerstones at some of the game’s most important positions. |
|
54 |
![]() NICO COLLINS
Houston · WR (X)
|
| With a prolific young quarterback drafted and in place in C.J. Stroud, Nico Collins reached breakout star status in 2023 as a multi-threat, 6-4, 215-pound X-receiver with both boundary-threatening ability and YAC production off of intermediate routes over the middle.
“He’s awesome — combo of size, speed and RAC ability,” an AFC scout told ESPN. Collins’ big contract extension comes off a 1,297-yard campaign in which advanced data/analytics tell the best story. He ranked only behind Tyreek Hill in yards per route run (3.11), first in EPA/target vs man coverage, first among WRs in Pro Football Reference‘s broken tackles stat (16) and fourth versus zone. He was third in ESPN‘s ‘Catch’ score and overall efficiency metric and second in ‘YAC’ score among pass catchers, while also grading third-best at his position by PFF. Reception Perception had him in the 96th percentile among WRs in success rate versus press coverage and 94th percentile against man coverage. He has the body size and typical skills of a stud X-receiver, with the smoothness and after-the-catch ability to play tough and elusive on concepts such as dig routes. PFF also graded him fourth among WRs in run blocking last year. He’s a unique player and as the Houston Texans predict to become a bigger story in coming years, so should Nico Collins. |
|
53 |
![]() MARK ANDREWS
Baltimore · TE
|
| Andrews has been (and remains) the top non-Lamar Jackson offensive weapon the Ravens have had over the past five seasons with Jackson at the helm.
He was on pace for another solid season last year before injury. His 10-game regular season graded out as the third-best among TEs by PFF. It’s his third season grading in the top-3 at his position. He also spent 72.6% of his snaps in the slot before he went down. He was also second among TEs in ESPN‘s pass catcher efficiency metric, and first in Open Score. He also tied Tyreek Hill for the highest share of an offense’s red zone targets (44%). “He’s still a monster target in the middle of the field, huge catch radius, a matchup issue for safeties and a bruiser after the catch,” an NFL personnel evaluator said to ESPN. He returns for his age-29 season as the game’s most complete tight end outside of San Francisco, and Baltimore’s usage of him and Isaiah Likely should let the Ravens veer back toward more 12 personnel on offense. |
|
52 |
![]() TRAVIS KELCE
Kansas City · TE
|
| Kelce had a career-low in yards per catch (10.6) last season, and his receiving yards (984) and TD (5) numbers were also pretty close to his lowest marks. Still, he turned it on in the postseason (32 catches, 355 yards, 4 TDs in four games) when he was needed most, and PFF graded him second among TEs in overall play and first in receiving.
He spent 417 snaps in the slot last year compared to 360 inline and 217 out wide. I like to call him Mahomes’ “binky” in big moments due to his ability to find soft spots in zone coverage and wiry ability to beat man coverage, even in his older age. He’ll be 35 years old in October. His play over a full 17-game season won’t match the extraordinary five to seven year stretch he had before 2023, but he’s still one of the game’s best and most unique pass catchers. He’s the all-time leader in receptions (165) in the playoffs, and he’s second in receiving yards (1,903) and TDs (19). He owns those records for a reason. |
|
51 |
![]() TRENT MCDUFFIE
Kansas City · CB
|
| As Sneed moved outside to the boundary, McDuffie took his spot in the nickel role last year. He earned First-team All-Pro honors in there in the slot, grading out as the 4th best cornerback in football by PFF, and first in pass rush.
“Pure, more fluid corner in space than Sneed,” and NFL coordinator said. “Might not be as physical as him but that’s coming with experience — he has that gear. He’s going to be a great one.” “…He’s about as good as they come with technique, footwork, quickness and feel,” an NFC executive told ESPN. “He continually shows up with big plays in key moments.” McDuffie led the league in slot coverage snaps (673) last year, but ironically, he will look to replace Sneed’s role again in 2024. Early reports out of training camp have McDuffie projected to play outside, perhaps as a boundary option versus opposing team’s best receivers, a challenge Sneed was often met with last year. The Chiefs also led the league in press coverage snaps (230) last year per ESPN, so McDuffie may be in line for several press snaps on the outside. Still, several top pass catchers move around from the perimeter to the slot on a snap-to-snap basis in today’s NFL, so McDuffie may find his role being more of a mix than Sneed’s was last year. Wherever he plays, it’s clear McDuffie has the chops to play both on the outside, and in the slot as a cover man, run stuffer or blitzing pass rusher. |
|
50 |
![]() JAYLEN WADDLE
Miami · WR (X/Z)
|
| Mike McDaniel’s offense’s has several different elements that make it a tough-to-defend unit.
Last year, Tua Tagovailoa led the NFL in pass attempts in zero or one step drops, and TD passes on plays with pre-snap motion (10). Miami was also second in Pistol formation usage (20% of snaps) and third in formation width, via PFF. In addition to their proclivity to condensed formations, the Dolphins were the only team with two WRs to have over 2.5 yards per route run (min. 50 catches). The Dolphins were also the only team to feature two Top-10 WRs in terms of PFF grade (Tyreek Hill – 1st, Jaylen Waddle – 7th). In addition to McDaniel’s ingenious ability to create plays, the Dolphins thrive because of their two versatile and speedy receivers. Both Hill and Waddle are explosive and dynamic at all three levels, and it’s Waddle who should more praise than he’s been given. Waddle has spent more time as the boundary X receiver in Miami’s offense than Hill. “Elite speed and an underrated route runner,” an NFL offensive coach said to ESPN. Waddle is just two seasons removed from leading the league in yards per catch (18.1 in 2022). Think of him as a unique gadget/designed target threat with A-/B+ route-running and other tools that make a top-end WR1 (vertical speed, elite acceleration, YAC ability, solid hands). He shows tremendous burst both before and after the catch, and is just as deadly on a long drag route as he is on a designed screen. I seem to be a bit higher on Waddle than most, as I see him as a clear Top-10 receiver. The 25-year old has many top-end seasons ahead. He signed a three-year contract extension with Miami this offseason. |
|
49 |
![]() TYLER SMITH
Dallas · OG/OT
|
| After he was forced to replace Tyron Smith at left tackle as a rookie in 2022, Tyler Smith moved to left guard last season and took a giant step forward.
“Giant” is fitting when discussing Smith, who’s frame (6-6, 332 pounds) is large, even for an NFL guard. He was named Second-team All-Pro last season. He was one of three Cowboys offensive lineman to be named an All-Pro (Zack Martin, Tyron Smith). His allowed pressure rate (2.8%) ranked fifth among his position, according to PFF. He did an excellent job versus fellow rising star (future superstar?) Jalen Carter from division rival Philadelphia, and the two may match up against each other for seasons to come. The Cowboys are ushering in a new left tackle this season in rookie Tyler Gutyon, who Dallas drafted in the first round. There was talk of Smith moving back over to left tackle before the draft, but now he’s solidified at left guard. He’ll help usher in the new era of dominant offensive line play for a franchise that has been near the forefront there for almost a decade. |
|
48 |
![]() DK METCALF
Seattle · WR (X)
|
| Last year I called Metcalf a “Greek God” and built-in-a-lap prototype at the X-receiver spot in the NFL.
He’s 6-4, 235 pounds and ran a 4.33 40-yard dash and posted a 40.5 vertical jump coming into the league. He’s proved to be one of the NFL’s best operators on the boundary, and he’s shown better route-running and lateral ability than projected coming out of college. Last year, Metcalf posted a career-high 16.9 yards per catch (5th in NFL), and he was 12th among all pass catchers in ESPN‘s YAC score. To give more context, he had a better YPC number than the likes of Nico Collins, Mike Evans and Tyreek Hill, and a better YAC score than after-the-catch monsters such as David Njoku, A.J. Brown and Amon-Ra St. Brown. Although he’s liable to take slants to the house, he still runs mostly a vertical route tree. Last year, 42.4% of his routes were labeled vertical routes, good for third in the league (min. 50 receptions), per ESPN‘s Matt Bowen. With the creative and aggressive Ryan Grubb in from the University of Washington to run the offense, and Tyler Lockett and Jaxon-Smith Njigba rounding out the trio as Z-receiver and slot options, Metcalf is poised for a big season as Geno Smith’s top vertical threat once more. |
|
47 |
![]() JOE THUNEY
Kansas City · OG
|
| Thuney was named First-team All-Pro at guard for the first time in his career last season. He remains the best pass-blocking guard in the NFL.
For the third consecutive season, he led all guards in PFF pass block grade and pash rush win rate (99.1%). “Grip strength — once he’s attached, he stays attached,” said an AFC executive said to ESPN regarding Thuney’s pass blocking. “Incredibly fundamental.” Thuney is also an iron man. He’s played and started in all 129 career regular season games. But he suffered a pec injury in the playoffs last year that sidelined him from the rest of the team’s Super Bowl run. He’ll turn 32 this season, so age is something to monitor, but he remains an elite interior blocker for the game’s best quarterback. |
|
46 |
![]() FRANK RAGNOW
Detroit · C
|
| Ragnow had a career year last season, earning Second-team All-Pro honors and helping to lead a Lions offense and team that became one of the best stories of the league in 2024.
Offensive coordinator Ben Johnson has the Lions featuring a litany of diverse run concepts such as pin-pull, where Detroit relies on Ragnow’s athleticism (often as a puller). He was PFF‘s top-graded center in run blocking (91.3) and overall play (88.8) in 2023, and along with Penei Sewell and others, Ragnow helps make up what is probably the best offensive line unit in the league. |
|
45 |
![]() CREED HUMPHREY
Kansas City · C
|
| Even with Jason Kelce still in the league last year, I had Creed Humphrey as the top center on my list. Now with Kelce retired, it’s no surprise he’s the top center on my list again.
“Extremely consistent, especially in pass pro, good athlete, very smart and tough and very, very steady,” an NFL personnel director told ESPN. “A great communicator and field general. Became better than I gave him credit for coming out.” In his first two seasons, Humphrey led all centers in overall PFF grade and run blocking grade before slipping to fourth and sixth in those metrics in 2023. But he was second in the NFL to only teammate Joe Thuney in pass block win rate (98%). Since Tyreek Hill’s exit in 2021, the Chiefs have shifted from more of a spread offense to a YAC-oriented passing attack with power-running concepts. The Chiefs were fifth among teams in their usage of gap runs last year, according to PFF. Humphrey represents the shift to a more physical, nasty unit up front. “We want to be known as one of the most physically dominating lines in the league, and we have the guys who can do it,” Humphrey told the Chiefs’ in-house reporters two summers ago. “That’s our entire outlook. When teams play us, we want them to know that they’re playing a physical offensive line that finishes through the whistle. We’re excited to get to work on that.” |
|
44 |
![]() TREVOR LAWRENCE
Jacksonville · QB
|
| Last year I was anticipating Jacksonville beginning a stretch of AFC South dominance, and Trevor Lawrence and Jacksonville perhaps vaulting to nemesis status for Patrick Mahomes and Kansas City. The arrival of C.J. Stroud and others in Houston, along with the Jaguars disappointing 2023 campaign has tempered those expectations, but I am still a big believer in Lawrence.
It was clear Lawrence was pressing last year to account for a subpar operation in Jacksonville. At times, it felt very Andrew Luck-ish. Lawrence was in the top-five in turnover worthy plays (24) and turnovers (21) last year, with the Jaguars finishing 29th in pass block win rate and 27th in run block win rate, per ESPN. However, Lawrence also was in the top-five in PFF‘s big-time throws metric (33), with a league-leading 20 of those being 20 yards or more downfield. He also is less than two years removed from a magnificent stretch in the second-half of 2022 where he rivaled Patrick Mahomes and Joe Burrow as the top QB in the game during that period. Doug Perderson’s offense continues to features a heavy dose of 12 personnel both under-center and in the shotgun. Per PFF, the Jaguars ranked fifth in gap run usage and 28th in zone run usage last year. Calvin Ridley is out, but first-round rookie Brian Thomas Jr. and free agent Gabe Davis take his place as perimiter threats with Christian Kirk threatening teams vertically from the slot. Travis Etienne Jr. is a solid running back who made this list last year. The Jaguars suddenly have a lot of competition in the AFC South, and although there are some pieces to help Lawrence, a lot still rests on his shoulders. |
|
43 |
![]() AMON-RA ST. BROWN
Detroit · WR (Slot/Z)
|
| Arguably the toughest receiver in football, St. Brown earned a hefty contract extension following a First-team All-Pro season that solidified him as one of the best high-volume receivers in the league.
“Has elite football instincts for the position,” an NFL coordinator said to ESPN. “Understands how to attack leverage. Runs hard every play. Plays inside and outside. Makes all the tough catches on high-leverage downs. Blocks, plays physical…” Last season St. Brown ranked second in the NFL in receptions (119) and yards after catch (668), and third in receiving yards (1,515) and first downs (75). He also caught a career-high 10 touchdowns and was graded third among his peers in PFF receiving grade (91.3) for the second season in a row. Per PFF, St. Brown spent 587 snaps in the slot last season, and had a career-high 592 snaps out wide. He’s becoming much more of a moveable Z-receiver than pure slot at this point, but his bread and butter is still working the middle part of the field on money downs and off of play-action. Per Field Vision Sports, St. Brown had the highest Total EPA against ‘Middle of the Field Open’ coverages (Cover-2, Cover-4, Cover-6) last year. “He’s really tough,” an NFC offensive coach told ESPN. “You know where the ball is going on third down and he’s usually coming up with it.” Reception Perception charted St. Brown in the 86th percentile in success rate versus zone coverage last year, and NFL Next Gen Stats had St. Brown with third-most yards on in-breaking routes among pass catchers. In last year’s list, I called St. Brown “Golden Tate crossed with Julian Edelman, with more of Edelman’s route tree.” St. Brown arguably had a better season than Tate or Edelman ever produced last year. |
|
42 |
![]() BRANDON AIYUK
San Francisco · WR (X)
|
| One of the the most discussed players of the 2024 offseason, Aiyuk is seeking a major deal after an All-Pro season (Second-team) in which he proved his worth as a top-tier X-receiver and route-runner.
He led all pass catchers in ESPN‘s ‘Catch’ Score (97) and receiver efficiency metric (96) last season, with both grading scales being 0 to 100. He was also second in yards per catch (17.9), 20-yard+ receptions (28), PFF receiving grade (91.7) and PFF overall grade among WRs (91.5). Reception Perception charted Aiyuk in the 96th percentile in man coverage success rate and 97th percentile in success rate versus press coverage with 80% of his sampled snaps on the boundary and 84% on the line. He was also 91st percentile in success rate versus zone coverage, and his Reception Perception ‘Success By Route‘ chart for last year looks like no other chart we’ve ever seen. Per Field Vision Sports, Aiyuk was third in Total EPA last year. His Wide Receiver Profile included a heat chart that showcased his ability to win in the intermediate part of the field. Personally, when I think of Aiyuk in San Francisco, I think of him lining up to the left (sometimes tight to the formation) and running a 10-to-15 yard dig off of play-action better than any WR in the league. If there was ever a time to produce a career year for leverage for a big contract, Aiyuk delivered at the best possible time. Still, San Francisco is a bit cap-strapped (Brock Purdy mega deal in 2025?) when looking at their team-building roadmap. There was also chatter about the 49ers’ pass catchers ability to beat Chiefs defensive backs in the Super Bowl 58 loss, but Aiyuk quietly won a few battles during his game-long war with L’Jarius Sneed. If Aiyuk does end up playing elsewhere in 2024, it’ll likely be on a new contract, and perhaps he’ll be set out to prove his worth as a scheme-agnostic X-receiver who can produce anywhere (I believe he can). |
|
41 |
![]() ZACK MARTIN
Dallas · OG
|
| Martin was named First-team All-Pro for the fifth consecutive season (and seventh time overall) last year. He’s the best guard of the in the NFL over the last 10-15 years.
He’ll turn 34 during this season, and some of his advanced analytics/PFF grading were down last year, but he still was fifth among interior offensive lineman in run block win rate (75%), and is overall one of the best run-blocking guards in football even in 2024. Tyron Smith left Dallas after 13 seasons this offseason, but Ezekiel Elliott is back in town as the lead back for the Cowboys. Martin and teammate Tyler Smith (a fellow All-Pro guard and Top 101 list member) will steer the ship up front for a Cowboys offensive line that was 4th in run block win rate last season, but 16th in Run DVOA. They can be better, and they need to get back to their dominant ways of the late 2010s up front to make this offense more well-rounded again. |
|
40 |
![]() GEORGE KITTLE
San Francisco · TE
|
| Kittle was named First-team All-Pro for the second time last season, and PFF graded him as the top overall tight end for the third time. He’s the best overall tight end in the game heading into 2024.
He led all tight ends in receiving yards (1,020), yards per catch (15.7), 20-yard+ receptions (19) and yards per route run (2.2) last year. He also graded first among TEs in PFF run blocking grade (81.1) yet again. “Deep in-breaking routes, delays and boots and keepers — he’s just a problem with the ball in his hands,” an NFL personnel director said to ESPN. “He’s more explosive [than Kelce] at this point, and being able to stay a little bit healthier this year helped him.” Field Vision Sports had Kittle with the second-most EPA on “Go” routes last year, behind only Tyreek Hill. And ESPN had Kittle tied for fourth among all pass catchers in YAC Score and sixth in their overall receiving efficiency metric. Even with the ascension of Brandon Aiyuk and unique qualities of Deebo Samuel, I think Kittle remains the 49ers best gamebreaking pass catcher in their arsenal. He’s the best non-Christian McCaffrey/Trent Williams player on a stacked and star-studded offense. |
|
39 |
![]() LAREMY TUNSIL
Houston · OT
|
| Tunsil enteres his age-30 season as one of the tow or three best pass-protecting tackles and more underrated players in the NFL.
“A little selective with his effort, but his playoff game against Myles Garrett is all you need to watch,” an NFL executive said to ESPN. Tunsil is second among all offensive tackles in PFF pass blocking grade (91.6) since joining the Texans in 2016. Under offensive coordinator Bobby Slowik, the Texans are primarily a zone-running team, and Tunsil’s quick-moving feet at his size (6-5, 313 lbs) is one of the offense’s best attributes on a unit that now has many stars, including young phenom QB C.J. Stroud. With Joe Mixon in the fold as an ideal zone-rushing lead back, Houston should be able to reach another level offensively in 2024. |
|
38 |
![]() JOSH HINES-ALLEN
Jacksonville · EDGE
|
| Hines-Allen took a major leap in Year 5. Per NFL Next Gen Stats, he posted career-highs in pressure rate (19.6%), defensive stops (49), sacks (17.5) and pressures (96).
In last year’s last, it was mentioned that he needed to generate more sacks after posting just 7 sacks with 64 pressures in 2022. His aforementioned sack and pressure numbers were both second in the NFL in 2023. His 96 pressures were the fourth-highest number of any defender in a single season since 2018. It’s safe to say he rose to the challenge. The Jaguars extended him with a massive deal in April. If more high-end production comes in 2024, it may somewhat be tied to the arrival of defensive coordinator Ryan Neilsen, who is getting rave reviews by many in the NFL community. Nielsen’s background is primarily as a defensive line coach at N.C. State (2013-2016) and with the Saints (2017-2022). He also held assistant head coach and defensive coordinator titles in New Orleans, and was the Falcons DC last season, where Atlanta was second in their usage of a 3-3-5 front (59.3%), per Arjun Menon’s The Scout. Like Atlanta last year, the Jaguars use 3-4 principles, but were fifth in 2-4-5 front usage (51.5%) last year. Jacksonville added Arik Armstead to play inside this offseason, and if they roll with three-down fronts, it would likely be Travon Walker playing on the line, while Allen continues to play in a two-point stance as a stand-up EDGE, where he excels. |
|
37 |
![]() CHRISTIAN DARRISAW
Minnesota · OT
|
| He missed nine games last year due to injury, but when healthy he is one of the most well-rounded offensive tackles in the league, which prompted his recent mega-contract extension.
“Excellent combination of strength, athleticism and well-rounded production in both phases,” an NFL personnel director said to ESPN. “The body control stands out.” “He’s a star,” another NFL personnel evaluator told ESPN. “Has the most upside of maybe all of them.” Darrisaw was third among his peers in PFF pass block grading (85.3), and he’s a solid run blocker for the Vikings’ zone-heavy rushing scheme. |
|
36 |
![]() JORDAN MAILATA
Philadelphia · OT
|
| Mailata is one of the best current stories in league as a former Australian rugby player turned NFL star via the league’s International Pathway Program.
He was graded third among his positional peers in overall PFF grade last season. He was also fifth in run block grade and sixth in pass blocking grade among offensive tackles. At 6-8, 345 pounds, he is one of the largest humans in the league to date. His size, skills, background and progression as a pro perfectly exemplify Eagles GM Howie Roseman’s strategy as a team-building genius. Philly struggled offensively down the stretch last season, and they now have new offensive coordinator Kellen Moore in the fold to alter the offense. Regardless of how the Eagles run the ball in 2024, they should do it well. Philadelphia led the NFL in run block win rate last year, and the top three offensive lineman in individual run block win rate were all Eagles. Mailata was second among offensive tackles in the metric (80%), behind teammate Lane Johnson. Eagles guard Landon Dickerson was first among all interior offensive lineman. |
|
35 |
![]() JUSTIN HERBERT
L.A. Chargers · QB
|
| Herbert and the Chargers had a rough go last season, which ended with him missing the last four games of the year due to injury.
He’s a very talented passer with a cannon for an arm, but similar to my Trevor Lawrence blurb, there’s a Andrew Luck-ish pressing from him as he tried to elevate a subpar offense. “Big, strong, fast, powerful arm,” an AFC personnel evaluator said to ESPN. “Will stare down some targets and try to make some hero-type plays at times — holding the ball too long and throwing into tight windows — but he has everything you want. Touch, velocity, size, athletic ability.” Herbert was fifth in QBR when pressured last season (75), and third in PFF passing grade while under pressure. He’s also the NFL’s all-time leader in pass attempts per game (39.1). Under Jim Harbaugh and Greg Roman, the Chargers will shift their offense to being a strong unit in the trenches, with a power running game to help provide an offensive basis and support aspect for Herbert. He should be able to recalibrate as a play-action passer who can dropback pass when called upon. Although the Chargers receiving core seems pretty barren at the moment, I am admittedly higher on rookie receivers Ladd McConkey and Brenden Rice (yes, Jerry Rice’s son) than most. This Chargers team should be on the rise by the end of the 2024 season. |
|
34 |
![]() LANE JOHNSON
Philadelphia · OT
|
| Johnson enters his age-34 season with three consecutive All-Pro years as arguably the best right tackle in all of football (certainly with Tristan Wirfs switching sides).
“I didn’t see any [drop-off],” an NFL scouting director said to ESPN. “He knows he’s getting close to the end and he’s been maintaining his level of play as a result.” Johnson led all offensive lineman in run block win rate (82%) last season. He was also the only right tackle to grade in the Top-15 in PFF‘s run block and pass block grade. He and Jordan Mailata make up the best tackle tandem in the league, leaving Philly in a great spot despite the retirement of future Hall-of-Famer Jason Kelce at center. Johnson may be a future Hall-of-Famer as well. |
|
33 |
![]() ROQUAN SMITH
Baltimore · LB
|
| To no one’s surprise, the Ravens were first in defensive DVOA last year, per Aaron Schatz and FTN Fantasy. Their usage of creative post-snap adjustments like simulated pressures and coverage switches flummoxed the best offensive innovators. Baltimore rocked Kyle Shanahan in San Francisco on Christmas night, and despite taking Baltimore to overtime with their his own unique offensive wrinkles, Sean McVay praised the Ravens defense in a recent episode of Robert Mays’ The Athletic Football Show.
But along with the departure of defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald are the losses of Patrick Queen, Jadeveon Clowney, Geno Stone and others on the defense. However, the unit’s unique playmaking and shutdown ability stem heavily from two All-Pro defenders in linebacker Roquan Smith and do-it-all safety Kyle Hamilton. Both are on this list, and we start with Roquan here. Smith had his fourth consecutive All-Pro season last year (second straight First-team honor), notching 158 tackles and a career-high eight pass deflections. He’s fantastic in coverage, at the line of scrimmage and as a blitzer. His athletic ability is matched only by his play diagnoses and football acumen. “Tremendous blitzer, very physical, plays with excellent power and leverage,” a veteran AFC coach said to ESPN. “…He covers a ton of ground in a hurry, great burst. Couldn’t be in a better spot than Baltimore.” Whenever the Ravens make a move, especially a high-profile one such as their trade for Smith in 2022, your ears should perk up. This was yet another shrewd move by Baltimore, who now has one of the game’s best defenders at an important spot. |
|
32 |
![]() QUINNEN WILLIAMS
N.Y. Jets · IDL
|
| Williams’ sack numbers were down last year compared to the season prior, and a year after being named First-team All-Pro he wasn’t named to the team this year, but he arguably played better in 2023 than he did in 2022.
Williams went from fourth to third in overall PFF grade (90.6) at his position and he was first among his peers in run defense grade (90.4). He was also second among non-nose tackle interior defenders in run stop win rate (38%), via ESPN. Furthermore, he was no slouch as a passer. He was first in third-down pressures (30) among his positional peers, according to Sports Info Solutions, and he was eighth in pass rush win rate, per ESPN. “Really good first step, and his size and athleticism overwhelms guys,” an NFL scouting director said to ESPN. “And he plays very hard, which is sometimes unique for guys at the position. Doesn’t really have any weakness.” The Jets are a San Francisco-esque defense that actually shifted from primarily a four-down unit to a three-down front in 2023. They led all teams in 3-3-5 usage (59.6%) last season, per Arjun Menon’s The Scout. It seems as if they are taking advantage of Williams’ disruption up front with scheme tweaks. Field Vision Sports projects Williams as their third-best interior defensive lineman for 2024 via their Havoc Rating. |
|
31 |
![]() DAK PRESCOTT
Dallas · QB
|
| Prescott was named an All-Pro (Second-team) for the first time in his career last year. In doing so, he led the league in touchdown passes (36) and QBR on third down (88.2), when pressured (65.4), when outside the pocket (81.8) and when inside the pocket.
He also was second in Total QBR (72.7), and per PFF, he led the league in big-time throws (37) and on-target percentage (82.6%), per Pro Football Reference. Prescott also was third among QBs in PFF pass grade. Prescott has shown the ability to elevate offenses and carry a team on his shoulders in the regular season. He’s even one of the few quarterbacks in the league capable of running an offense via pre-snap adjustments. Yet, his postseason appearances have resulted in heartbreak and agony. Considering the fact that it’s hard to find a quality quarterback in this league, Dallas finds themselves in a tough position with Prescott entering the final year of his second contract. Throughout his second deal, he’s ranked third among QBs in EPA per play, per TrueMedia, but the team has yet to get over the hump in the postseason. |
|
30 |
![]() CHRIS LINDSTROM
Atlanta · OG
|
| He was named Second-team All-Pro for the second straight season, but many believe he’s the best interior offensive lineman in the league, which is where I ranked him here.
“We’ve had him No. 1 for a few years now,” an AFC exec said to ESPN. He was PFF‘s top-graded guard for a second consecutive campaign while also grading third among his peers in run blocking and fifth in pass blocking. A Boston College alum, he’s long been a mauler in the run game, which was perfect for Arthur Smith’s run-heavy, power zone-rushing concepts. Zac Robinson is now calling the offense in Atlanta, where he’ll bring his McVay offensive principles to the Falcons. As stated in other blurbs in this piece, the McVay offense went through a change last year, shifting to more inside runs like duo. Because of this, they have prioritized size and quality in the interior at the guard spots, where you see players of that mold getting big deals in free agency. Needless to say, Lindstrom will fit in nicely with this system as well. |
|
29 |
![]() C.J. STROUD
Houston · QB
|
| The reigning Offensive Rookie of the Year had one of the most impressive Year 1’s for a NFL quarterback that we’ve ever seen. He perfectly navigated Bobby Slowik’s Shanahan offense while at times elevating the dropback passing game with his deft passing.
“He set the standard for a rookie QB,” an NFC executive told ESPN. “Has so much poise. He stands in the pocket and delivers the football. Stands tall. Doesn’t see colors coming at him.” Typical of a Shanahan offense, Stroud was asked to and excelled at making the right reads, taking care of the football and attacking the middle part of the field. Per Elias Sports Bureau, he was the first rookie to lead the NFL in TD-INT ratio (4.6). Stroud also led the league in QBR versus zone coverage (73.9), and was second to Brock Purdy in percentage of passes between 11-19 air yards (23.8%). He also played beyond his scheme, while consistently attacking defenses deep. Out of 30 qualifying QBs with over 260 pass attempts in 2023, Stroud led the league in average depth of target (9.1). He was the only QB since 200 to have an aDot of 9.0 or better with an interception rate of 1.0 or lower, per The 33rd Team. He was also first in EPA gained on passes of 20+ air yards, via Sports Info Solutions. Last year Stroud struggled some versus man coverage when Tank Dell went down, leaving only Nico Collins as a consistent coverage beater. This year Dell will return with Collins, and Stefon Diggs has been added to the lineup as a possible Z-receiver and slot option who should still be able to beat man coverage. Stroud won’t turn 23 years old until October, and he’s already widely seen as a Top-10 quarterback. Here I have him ranked sixth. The sky is the limit. Enjoy this, Texans fans. |
|
28 |
![]() MATTHEW STAFFORD
L.A. Rams · QB
|
| There’s a thought about modern quarterbacks here that probably warrants a longer discussion, but in short, with the proliferation of Shanahan/McVay-style offenses, QBs are often asked to play well in scheme and in structure, particularly on early downs. Often times reads are defined, and pre-snap adjustments are kept at a minimal compared to the Tom Brady and Peyton Manning-like field generals. But what happens when the game plan goes awry? These quarterbacks are often left vulnerable in drop-back passing situations, particularly in shotgun-spread on third downs, when full field progressions and pocket calmness are needed most.
The Rams got over the hump and won Super Bowl 56 because they exchanged Jared Goff for one of the best drop-back passers in the league in Stafford. Then, they blended McVay’s concepts (under-center, bootleg play-action, etc.) with Stafford’s ability to lineup in shotgun and diagnose the whole field. However, two years after their Super Bowl win, team-building decisions left the once all-in-to-win Rams with a barren roster worthy of a Top-10 pick in 2023. Still, McVay, Stafford and team were able to elevate the unit to a playoff team after winning seven of their last eight regular season games. Stafford was impressive, both in his on-field play (5th in PFF grade and 4th in pass grade among QBs) and leadership in ushering in Puka Nacua and delivering without Cooper Kupp for a period. Stafford and Nacua were the second-best duo in the league last year in Total EPA off of play-action passes, via Football Insights and FTN Fantasy. He also adjusted well to concepts foreign to him, like pre-snap motion. A year after Stafford had just 113 passes with pre-snap motion (31st in NFL), he threw 360 balls with the concepts (5th in NFL), per PFF and Sports Info Solutions. Entering his age-36 season, it’s worth wondering whether or not Stafford takes a major dip, or his passing skills erode. I’ll take my chances at least for this season with ranking him this high. |
|
27 |
![]() ANTOINE WINFIELD JR.
Tampa Bay · SAF
|
| Along with Baltimore’s Kyle Hamilton, Winfield was a First-team All-Pro safety after a monster 2023 campaign. He tallied 122 tackles, 26 defensive stops, 18 QB pressures, 12 pass deflections, six sacks, four forced fumbles, three fumble recoveries and three interceptions.
He was also fourth among all defenders in ball hawk rate (27.9%) per NFL Next Gen Stats. And he was PFF‘s top-graded safety in run defense (91.5) and overall play (90.7), and was second in pass rush grade (92.7). After spending more time in the slot/box as a nickel-type defender in 2022, Todd Bowles moved him back to more of a deep safety role in 2023. He was fifth in the NFL in deep-third snaps (911), per PFF and Sports Info Solutions. Still, he had a combined 454 defensive snaps in the box, in the slot or along the line of scrimmage, per PFF. His six sacks led all safeties, and four of his sacks came on third-down from a linebacker position. He had just 10 pass rush snaps from that position on third down, making that sack number ridiculous. He earned a the biggest contract for a defensive back in history this offseason, and Field Vision Sports has him as their top-ranked safety heading in to 2024 after he finished in the Top 10 in Havoc Rating in pass rush, run defense and zone coverage among his peers last season. |
|
26 |
![]() DAVANTE ADAMS
Las Vegas · WR (X)
|
| Now 31 years old, Adams could be entering the last season of his career where he’s expected to be an elite operator. He’s still one of the game’s very best route runners, if not, the best. He also wins his battles often without the need for speed.
I included it in last year’s piece as well, but Julian Edelman’s quote on Adams from a 2022 episode of The I Am Athlete Podcast has always stood out to me: “He’s quicker than what you think,” Edelman said. “He can run run by you, has great separation, great catch radius. You can play him everywhere, and we saw that with the Packers the last couple years. His versatility, his size, his quickness…he’s not the fastest guy, but he’s never not open, because he had the back shoulder thing going with Aaron Rodgers.” Adams has played through some disfunction. He’s had five different starting quarterbacks in two seasons in Las Vegas, and has led the league in target share in each of the last two seasons (min. 250 routes run), per Sumer Sports. A year after being named First-team All-Pro he suffered a dip in numbers. His yards per catch numbers dropped dramatically and his PFF WR grade was 21st after four straight seasons of being in the Top-4. He also spent less time in the slot in 2023, which is a position in which he thrives as an immediate man-coverage beater (particularly off press) from the inside with the threat of a two-way go. Per Reception Perception‘s sampled charting, Adams had a career-high percentage of snaps on the line (85.8%) and most snaps on the outside since 2016 (87.5%). In Vegas, he’s been strictly an X-receiver. Still, I think he remains a borderline Top-5 WR heading into this year. Some advanced analytics showcase his value even through the mess that has been the Raiders offense. His 85.7 career PFF grade in the red zone is the highest ever charted, and PFF had him first in “THREAT %” in the red zone last year. He also was above the 90th percentile versus press coverage in Reception Perception‘s charted snaps for the fifth straight year. |
|
25 |
![]() KYLE HAMILTON
Baltimore · SAF
|
| A star at Notre Dame in college, Hamilton entered the NFL Draft process as one of the most highly-touted prospects before a slower 40-yard dash time (4.59) and combine critique caused him to fall to the No. 14th pick in the ’22 NFL Draft, where the Ravens, one of the savvier franchises in sports, snagged one of their biggest steals.
The 6-foot-4, 220 pound Swiss Army knife is listed as a safety, but is essentially positionless. PFF charted him with several snaps in the slot (465), as a deep safety (301) and in the box (236). He also had 58 snaps along the line of scrimmage as a potential blitzer. He was the only safety to register a 90+ PFF grade in pass rush (92.8; 1st among safeties) and pass coverage (3rd; 90.1), and he added four interceptions, three sacks, 13 pass deflections and 10 tackles for a loss. Per Arjun Menon’s The Scout, Baltimore led the NFL in 2-4-5 fronts on defense (72.8% of snaps), and was third in Big Nickel formations featuring three safeties (463). There are two meanings to “Big Nickel” at this juncture, with one being the formation (three safeties), and the other being the position as a bigger slot defender who can not only cover, but fit the run game like a psuedo-linebacker, as well as blitz the quarterback. Hamilton led all players in pressure rate (30%) last season when rushing the passer and is just one of five safeties with at least 20 run stops in fewer than 200 run snaps since coming into the league in 2022. But where he really makes his mark is as a roaming defender with his eyes on the quarterback, particularly at the second level/in the box. On Yahoo Sports‘ “Football 301 Podcast,” writer and podcast host Charles McDonald perfectly and hilariously describes Hamilton as a “Pterodactyl in the box that can do just about anything on a football field.” In addition to the losses of defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald, linebacker Patrick Queen and EDGE Jadeveon Clowney, Baltimore also lost safety Geno Stone to Cincinnati. To keep their Big Nickel 2-4-5 defense intact, they’ve added Eddie Jackson presumably to play a bit more deep with Marcus Williams while Hamilton remains at the first two levels as a chess piece closer to the football and line of scrimmage. |
|
24 |
![]() AIDAN HUTCHINSON
Detroit · EDGE
|
| Hutchinson made the jump to top-tier EDGE defender in Year 2, racking up 11.5 sacks and 33 QB hits. He often was working as a one-man pass rushing crew for a Lions team that heavily relied on it defensively.
Hutchinson played the second-most snaps of any D-lineman in the NFL last season, and he accounted for 37.4% of Detroit’s overall pressures. “High ceiling. He will be the next Nick Bosa,” an NFL scouting director said to ESPN. “Banking on him getting even better. Highly disruptive, physical, near rare motor.” Per NFL Next Gen Stats, Hutchinson also led the NFL in games with 5+ pressures with a whopping 16 such games. He was four games ahead of the next closest in that category (Nick Bosa). PFF, which seems to chart pressures a bit differently/generously, had Hutchinson second in the league in quarterback pressures with 101. It was only the fifth time they charted over 100 QB pressures for a single season since 2006. Detroit has aspirations of a Super Bowl win this season, but to do so they’ll need more help opposite Hutchinson on the edge. In addition to adding D.J. Reader inside to help the surging Alim McNeill, the Lions signed former first-round pick Marcus Davenport to rush the passer on the edge. They also used heavy resources to shore up their outside CB spot. They drafted Terrion Arnold and Ennis Rakestraw Jr. in Rounds 1 and 2 and brought in Carlton Davis in free agency. That, along with Brian Branch’s work in the nickel role has Detroit projected to be much better defensively. In terms of scheme, this is a 4-down defense under defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn. Per Arjun Menon’s The Scout, the Lions ran a Nickel/Big Nickel 4-2-5 or 4-3 defense on a combined roughly 76% of snaps. |
|
23 |
![]() TRISTAN WIRFS
Tampa Bay · OT
|
| After three seasons at right tackle, Wirfs moved over to the left side last year, where his dominant play continued. PFF has graded him as a Top-10 tackle in each of his four seasons in the NFL. Last year he was also second among offensive tackles in PFF pass blocking grade (85.5).
“He’s so f—ing talented that, even though it was an adjustment early in the year and he had been dominant on the right side, he started to play at a high level later and was much better as the season progressed,” an NFL personnel evaluator told ESPN. “Super athlete, real light feet, broad, slides well.” “The things he can do at his size are rare,” an AFC scout said to ESPN. Earlier this month, Tampa made him the highest-paid offensive lineman in NFL history. After spending time back and forth with the Los Angeles Rams and the University of Kentucky, Liam Coen comes to Tampa Bay as offensive coordinator, where a McVay-esque offense is projected. Considering that, expect Tampa to look to the run game a bit more, whether that be outside zone, duo/inside runs, or a likely mix. The early returns on first-round pick Graham Barton at center look promising, and as the linchpin of the offensive line, expect Wirfs to have a few wow plays in run blocking this season, in addition to his pass blocking prowess. |
|
22 |
![]() A.J. BROWN
Philadelphia · WR (X)
|
| Brown is a unique receiver who has size (6-1, 226 lbs) and skills that lend itself to top-tier play in the slot, on the perimeter, underneath, in the deep intermediate (posts), on schemed touches, on flys, breaking tackles after the catch, you name it.
Despite the Eagles’s struggles, he had a second consecutive solid season in Philly, topping the 1,400-yard mark again and leading the NFL in production on the outside (most receiving yards/first downs on outside, per PFF.) As the last stat suggests, he spent a lot of time on the outside last season. But he followed it up with exemplary X-receiver play. Reception Perception charted him in the 96th percentile in success rate versus both man coverage and press. Brown was given a multi-year ≈$100 million contract extension for the second consecutive offseason. By any measure, he is a Top-5 receiver in the league. To put a bow on his praise through data, ESPN Analytics had Brown second in their overall receiver efficiency metric (96 grade out of 100), fourth in ‘Catch’ score and fifth in ‘Open’ score. Brown was also third in NFL Next Gen Stats‘ receptions over expected metric. With Kellen Moore in town, it’s worth wondering how he’ll use both Brown and DeVonta Smith this season. I mentioned earlier that Smith may seem more time as a flanker or in the slot, but I think Brown may return to more snaps inside as well. |
|
21 |
![]() PATRICK SURTAIN JR.
Denver · CB
|
| The Broncos are a work in progress in the Sean Payton era. They are not in the best spot when it comes to their overall roster (although I think they will be better than many think), but they do have one star in Surtain.
In terms of PFF grading and advanced analytics, he had a bit of a regression season last year after earning First-team All-Pro honors in 2022. On last year’s list I pointed out that NFL Films‘ Greg Cosell said he “spoke to a couple of people that believe he’s the best corner in football,” on the The Xs and Os with Greg Cosell. There are still many in the NFL community that see him the same way. “He did not have the best year,” an NFL coordinator said to ESPN. “But he’s still the best pure talent, he moves the best, and you can do the most with him as far as coverage, so if I’m starting a team, I’m probably picking him.” “Complete corner that can play in any coverage and has size, instincts, ball skills and will tackle,” an NFL personnel director told ESPN. “I like the corners that can do it all.” In terms of technique and scheme-agnostic play, the 6-foot-2, 202 pound Surtain still may be top dog at corner. If I had to predict, I’d say I’d have him back as the top cornerback on this list in the future, but I had to give someone else that moniker heading into this season. |
|
20 |
![]() CEEDEE LAMB
Dallas · WR (Slot/X)
|
| Lamb became a bonafide superstar last season, earning All-Pro honors and along with Dak Prescott and some solid offensive line play, practically carried the Cowboys offense as an un-guardable receiver and fantastic playmaker.
He was first in targets (181), receptions (135), yards after catch (680) and receptions over expected (per NFL Next Gen Stats) last year. He was second in receiving yards (1,749), receiving touchdowns (12), touchdowns on vertical routes (9; per NFL Next Gen Stats) receiving yards before contact (1,069) and ESPN‘s open score. He was also fourth in PFF WR grade and ESPN‘s receiver efficiency metric, and third in PFF‘s “THREAT %” metric on all routes run. Lamb has spent just over 50% of his snaps in the slot in each of the last two seasons, and when he’s not inside, he’s usually lined up off the line of scrimmage. But Reception Perception charted him on the line on 40% of his sampled snaps in 2023 to go along with a a 94 percentile charting in success rate versus both man and press coverage. Make no mistake, Lamb could be a full-time X-receiver if a team so chooses. “He was able to move around the formation more this year, specifically outside, and he consistently won in critical situations over the course of the year,” an NFL scouting director said to ESPN. “He proved to be a do-it-all receiver. Has great hands and outstanding pace to his routes and setup that gives defensive backs problems.” Similar to Brandon Aiyuk’s 2023 ‘Success By Route’ chart, Lamb’s reads all green on every common route concept. He’s a force of nature, and must be double covered. Dipping into the advanced machine-learning data world — Field Vision Sports‘ ‘Threat Rating’ had Lamb as the the NFL’s third-best receiver. Lamb also hadthe best ‘raw’ Threat Rating among WRs last season, and the top mark in the slot and versus man coverage. Receiver-franchise contract stand-offs are the norm nowadays, and the Cowboys and Lamb need to reach an agreement on a new deal. Dallas should offer whatever he asks (within cap space/team-building reason). |
|
19 |
![]() JA’MARR CHASE
Cincinnati · WR (Z/Slot)
|
| Despite being the third-ranked receiver on my list for the second straight year, Chase would be my pick for the league’s No. 1 receiver in say, 2026 or 2027. He’s had three fantastic seasons as it is, but at just 24 years old, there’s another level to be reached.
Despite playing almost half of last season with Jake Browning starting at quarterback, Chase had a career-high 100 catches for 1,216 yards and 8 TDs. After beginning his career almost exclusively as an X-receiver, he spent more time moving around the formation as a flanker or slot option in 2023. Per PFF, he had a career-high 216 slot snaps. And 40% of his sampled Reception Perception charted snaps had him off the line of scrimmage. With two vertical boundary options in Cincy now in Tee Higgins and rookie Jermaine Burton, it’s worth wondering if Chase may spend over half of his snaps in the slot to replace Tyler Boyd this season. Chase was second among WRs in PFF‘s “THREAT %” metric from the slot. And in a true showcase of his after-the-catch skill, he had a near league-low average depth of target from the slot (4.7) while also sporting the third-most yards per route run (2.57) from the alignment. You can also expect Chase to be used more in motion both before and at the snap, as the Bengals continue to experiment more there. But when he does play on the outside, he’ll also be one of the league’s very best out wide. He was in the 91st percentile of Reception Perception‘s success rate versus press coverage. In conclusion, Chase can do it all, and he’s only going to get better. Hear it from the experts: “He’s still the league’s best vertical threat and yards-after-catch player,” a veteran NFL coordinator said to ESPN. “The fear factor with him is thick.” Similar to CeeDee Lamb in the blurb before him —Cincinnati would be wise to reach a deal with Chase on a lucrative extension, pronto. |
|
18 |
![]() SAUCE GARDNER
N.Y. Jets · CB
|
| Gardner has been named First-team All-Pro twice in each of his first two years in the league. At 6-foot-3, 190 pounds, his length and coverage skills make him the game’s top cornerback entering his age-24 season.
“He doesn’t get a lot of balls thrown at him,” a scouting director with an NFL team said. “He locks down and has been that good where teams throw away and don’t test him. That alone tells me something.” He was top CB in PFF coverage grade (90.8) for the second straight season last year, playing in Robert Saleh’s Cover-3 and Cover-4/Quarters heavy scheme that also implements man match principles. Last season, PFF charted him with 925 snaps out wide and just 15 snaps in the slot. Since 2022, Gardner has also led all cornerbacks in several advanced stat metrics, including: yards per coverage snap (0.53) and passer rating allowed (63), per PFF. Field Vision Sports projects Gardner as both its second-best man coverage CB and a Top-5 zone CB heading in Havoc Rating heading into 2024. His game is well rounded. |
|
17 |
![]() DEXTER LAWRENCE
N.Y. Giants · IDL
|
| Lawrence may already be pushing for the moniker of best pass-rushing nose tackle in NFL history. He’s produced back-to-back DOMINANT seasons with the Giants. He’s a force to be reckoned with.
“He’s just an awesome football player,” an AFC scout said to ESPN. “A unique combo of power, balance and lower-body flexibility, and you combine that with his football acumen and you have a premier player.” A year after grading out as PFF‘s top interior defender in both run defense and pass-rushing, Lawrence was their top-graded interior defensive lineman overall (92.9) in 2023. He was first in pass rush grade again among his peers (92.6), and third in run defense grade (89.5). The Giants were primarily a Nickel 3-3-5 team (58.4% of snaps, 3rd-most usage in NFL) in 2023 under ‘Wink’ Martindale. With new defensive coordinator Shane Bowen in the mix (Mike Vrabel tree), we can expect more Nickel/Big Nickel 2-4-5 looks up front, and perhaps a shift to even more usage of 3-4 “principles.” Lawrence is perfect for that mold. He can play in different spots in the inside, and he has. But he’s outright dominant at nose tackle. In 178 snaps directly over the center (0-tech) in 2023, Lawrence had a 94.7 PFF grade, with Vita Vea (81.6) the next closest. Additionally, Lawrence has 81 pressures lined up at nose tackle since 2022, the next closest is 16. Lawrence was also top-graded defender at 1-technique, and his 41 QB pressures at 0-tech or 1-tech last season were 30 (!) more than anyone else, per PFF. Only Aaron Donald (20%) and Chris Jones (20%) posted a better pash rush win rate than Lawrence (19%) last year among interior defenders. With Donald retired, Lawrence is battling Jones for title of best interior D-lineman in the league. |
|
16 |
![]() PENEI SEWELL
Detroit · OT
|
| There’s many reasons why the ascension of Dan Campbell’s Detroit Lions is good for the NFL, but the perhaps the most endearing element is how they built this juggernaut of a roster. A year before they drafted Aidan Hutchinson at No. 2 overall in 2022, they nabbed Sewell at pick No. 7. They prioritized the trenches. Each move has paid off, with Sewell in particular having a monster 2023 campaign at right tackle that saw him earn First-team All-Pro honors and a massive contract extension after the season.
“A dog, physically elite, improved every year,” an NFL coordinator said to ESPN. “Dominant run blocker and arguably the best anchor in pass protection,” an AFC executive said to ESPN. “Some OTs are great pass blockers but just average in the run game. He’s elite in both phases. Very consistent. Plays with an edge.” Sewell was first among all offensive lineman in PFF run block grade (95.1) and first among tackles in overall play (92.8). One of the league’s most powerful and diverse running games under offensive coordinator Ben Johnson, Sewell thrived in all areas, grading second among all offensive lineman in PFF zone run blocking (92.8) and first in gap run blocking (91.5). The Detroit Lions are my pick for Super Bowl 59 champion, and Sewell is my top-ranked Lion on this list. |
|
15 |
![]() FRED WARNER
San Francisco · LB
|
| Warner remains the new-age prototype at linebacker as an athletic, fast and cerebral defender who can diagnose and dominate at the second level. He can cover vertical routes up the seam, defend passes in shallow zones, or chase down speedy runners on outside zone rushes. He’s a sideline-to-sideline enforcer.
“He’s like an elite quarterback in terms of managing the game,” an NFL coordinator said to ESPN. “Checks, adjustments, unbelievable awareness and instincts. He allows the other 10 people around him to function at a high level collectively because of what he’s able to do mentally.” Warner had four interceptions, four forced fumbles and 2.5 sacks last season. He was PFF‘s second-highest graded linebacker (90) for the second straight year. He was also fourth at his position in run defense grade (90.3), sixth in coverage grade and eighth in pass rush. He was named First-team All-Pro for the third time in four seasons in 2023, and will continue to be an integral part of a 49ers defense that relies on a four-down front and Cover-3 match or Cover-4/Quarters coverage. |
|
14 |
![]() CHRISTIAN MCCAFREY
San Francisco · RB
|
| McCaffrey was the league’s Offensive Player of the Year in 2023. He enters this season as the NFL’s top running back and Madden cover athlete.
“He does everything exceptionally,” a veteran NFL offensive coach who coached him said to ESPN. “Explosiveness, vision, technique, versatility, great teammate, hardest worker, dedicated in the offseason. The only thing holding him back was when he was hurt. But he’s exactly how you would draw up a football player.” McCaffrey was first in rushing yards (1,459) and touchdowns (21 – tied with Raheem Mostert) in 2023. Per Pro Football Reference, he was first in yards before contact (853) and second in yards after contact (806). He also led the league in rushing yards over expectation (349), per NFL Next Gen Stats. San Francisco began running more gap concepts and inside runs in 2023, where McCaffrey garnered 4.9 yards per carry on inside runs, good for fourth among RBs. Still, San Francisco was second in outside zone usage (46% of run snaps), per MatchQuarters and PFF, and McCaffrey paced the league in zone-rush attempts with 219. A good chunk of those zone runs came on first down, where McCaffrey averaged a whopping 5.6 yards per carry. But its McCaffrey’s dual-threat ability that makes him so special. He had over 2,000 total yards last year, with 67 catches for 564 receiving yards and seven receiving scores. Only Marshall Faulk (4) has more seasons of 1,000+ rushing yards and 700+ receiving yards than McCaffrey’s three such campaigns. Field Vision Sports has McCaffrey as its top-ranked running back heading into 2024. He was second in their Threat Rating in routes run beyond the line of scrimmage, and was first last year among RBs in deep receiving EPA. |
|
13 |
![]() JOE BURROW
Cincinnati · QB
|
| Last offseason, Burrow was coming off two consecutive seasons of leading all QBs in PFF grade and leading the Bengals to a Super Bowl berth and AFC Championship Game. In training camp, he signed the then-largest contract in NFL history.
Last year, an injury ended his season after 10 games and a PFF QB grade and Total QBR good for 17th and 20th among NFL quarterbacks. Still, I’m not worried. Burrow remains in contention for best drop-back passer in the league, with the ball placement and pocket poise that many quarterbacks would be envious of. “Burrow is still probably the most consistent of all the guys,” an NFL executive said to ESPN. “A pure thrower who’s in complete command of the offense and comes up big in big moments. He knows when to attack and be aggressive vs. when to take the easy yards. And the dude is so tough.” “Baller. Release. Decision-making. Tough as nails,” a veteran NFC offensive coach told ESPN. “One play away from already having a ring. And young so the injury not as concerning.” Heading into last season, Burrow led the NFL in 20+ yard TD passes since 2021 (21). Despite his seen ability to operate as a deep-ball thrower, he’s ranked 29th and 35th the last two seasons in average depth of target. While Burrow thrives on fade passes to Tee Higgins and Ja’Marr Chase, Cincinnati also heavily uses WR screens with Chase as an option to pick up yards. The Bengals reportedly will lean on more under-center rushing and play-action passing concepts this season after Burrow spent 97% of his drop backs in shotgun last season, and 93% in shotgun in 2023. In terms of help surrounding Burrow, the tackle has been fortified with two giants in Trent Brown and rookie Amarius Mims to compete for snaps across from Orlando Brown. That and the addition of Zack Moss to replace Joe Mixon at running back spells more under-center inside runs. In the receiving core, newcomer Mike Gesicki and downfield rookie receiver threat Jermaine Burton suggest more “11.5” personnel and downfield shots. I see Gesicki as more of a shotgun, drop-back passing weapon than under-center, two-tight end formation player. Burton seems like a steady option in under-center 2-WR sets as a deep-shot artist. It’s worth wondering if he’ll eat into some of Tee Higgins snaps in what may be the receiver’s final year in Cincinnati. As I stated in this piece’s intro, I have the Bengals and Lions facing off in Super Bowl 59 in New Orleans. A lot of that hinges on Burrow’s return to play as an elite quarterback. |
|
12 |
![]() MAXX CROSBY
Las Vegas · EDGE
|
| As effective as he is tenacious, Crosby is among the best players in the league. If he was once underrated, any serious NFL watcher should realize his impact on games.
He had a career-high 14.5 sacks last season, but most notable was his dirty work in the run game. Among EDGE defenders, he was first in run stop win rate (36%). He also led the league in PFF‘s run defense grade (92.7) and he was the NFL’s leader in defensive stops (58) and tackles for loss (23; tied with Danielle Hunter) for the second straight year. In a profile piece with PFF last summer, Crosby said: “I’m not gonna stop until I get that recognition. I’m not gonna stop until I’m winning and whatever that takes. I’m willing to run that marathon and like, I don’t care if it’s year eight or nine until they’re like, ‘Yeah, Maxx is the best guy in the league.’ Field Vision Sports already has Crosby first in the league among EDGE defenders. He blew away his peers in Run Havoc Rating last season, according to their data. With Christian Wilkins added inside, Crosby should get even more opportunities on the edge this season. For now, he’ll continue to be the aggressor in practice in August before he takes the field versus another team in Week 1. |
|
11 |
![]() NICK BOSA
San Francisco · EDGE
|
| His sack numbers dropped from 18.5 to 10.5 last season, but Bosa still graded out as the third best EDGE defender by PFF in pass rushing and overall play. He also notched 27 total pressures in three playoff games, including 12 in Super Bowl 58 versus Patrick Mahomes with the season on the line.
“Awesome player — tough, explosive, can bend, can turn speed to power, plays his a– off,” an AFC executive said to ESPN. “Have to account for him all the time.” Bosa thrives mostly as a hand-in-the-dirt, 4-3-style defensive end, often in a Wide 9 alignment. Since 2021, he leads the NFL in sacks (50.5) and QB hits (115). The loss of Arik Armstead to Jacksonville will hurt, but the 49ers added Maliek Collins and Leonard Floyd along the defensive line to help get back some pass rush production. Floyd’s fit will be interesting in the 49ers’ 4-down front, as he’s mostly been used as a stand-up EDGE. |
|
10 |
![]() CHRIS JONES
Kansas City · IDL
|
| Last year, coming off a career year, I called Chris Jones the second-most important player in the Chiefs dynasty behind Patrick Mahomes, and the “Rodney Harrison” of their run due to his fiery attitude. He was integral to a Super Bowl run yet again in 2023, with several key rushes on Brock Purdy in Super Bowl 58 that potentially saved the game.
He and the Chiefs were finally able to come to a long-term deal this offseason, which is a scary thought for the rest of the league. As it is, he leads all interior defenders in sacks over the last three seasons (35), and he tied Aaron Donald for best pass rush win rate among interior defensive lineman in 2023 (20%). “His size and consistent dominant effort is just so hard to block,” an NFL executive said to ESPN. “He’s such a mismatch because of how long and strong he is, and he can win from every spot — edge, over center, in the B gap.” Although mostly an interior defender, Jones plays everywhere, even moving a bit outside to pass rush versus offensive tackles on third down passing situations. In Steve Spagnuolo’s four-down front defense last year, Jones spent 464 snaps in the B gap, 321 over the tackle and 154 outside the tackle, per PFF (regular + postseason). He’s a true inside-outside force. Field Vision Sports has Jones as it’s top-graded pass-rushing interior defensive lineman heading into 2024, with a 100 out of a 100 Pass Rush Havoc Rating. He enters his age-30 season coming off two straight First-team All-Pro seasons and five All-Pro seasons in six years. He’s one of the best players in the NFL, period. The Chiefs defense, and Super Bowl hopes, rely heavily on Jones’ health and play. |
|
9 |
![]() TRENT WILLIAMS
San Francisco · OT
|
| The future Hall-of-Famer enters his age-36 (!) season at the top of his game. Williams was named First-team All-Pro at left tackle for the third straight year. He was PFF‘s second-highest graded offensive tackle (92.6) after grading out first every year from 202o to 2022 (and in 2013, 2016).
“Does it all at a high level, still,” an NFL coordinator said to ESPN. “Protection, run game, second-level stuff downfield — no weakness in his game and I haven’t seen the skill set diminish.” Williams was also second among tackles in PFF run block grade (92.6) and first in zone run blocking grade (93.7) in 2023. He was also first in pass block win rate (96%). Like McVay’s offense in Los Angeles, Kyle Shanahan and San Francisco has veered toward more inside/gap runs to combat smaller, quicker NFL defenses. Still, the 49ers were second in outside zone usage (46% of run snaps), per MatchQuarters and PFF. That’s where Williams is able to showcase his raw athleticism in space at 6-foot-5, 320 pounds. I liken him to a stampeding elephant versus smaller defensive backs on those outside runs. It’s amazing that at this point, Williams’ prime has been his age 32-35 seasons. He’s the oldest player on my list this year, and I have him as the ninth best player in football, and best offensive lineman on the planet. He’s a special, special player. |
|
8 |
![]() JUSTIN JEFFERSON
Minnesota · WR (X/Slot)
|
| Before an injury ended his season, Jefferson was on his usual All-Pro pace in Year 4. In just 10 games, he caught 68 passes for 1,074 yards. He was second behind just Tyreek Hill in receiving yards per game (107.4).
The Vikings star was also one of just two WRs (Brandon Aiyuk) to earn a 90+ PFF grade versus both man (90.2) and zone coverage (90.6). He was also in the 90th percentile in success rate versus man and zone coverage on sampled Reception Perception snaps, and was in the 98th percentile in success rate versus press coverage. “He’s the best route runner in all of football in my opinion,” an NFL wide receivers coach said to ESPN. “Play speed. Constant production. Instincts. Elite hands. Do-it-all route runner,” another high-ranking NFL team personnel told ESPN. NFL Next Gen Stats charts Jefferson as the leader in receptions over expected (+27.6) since 2021. In using machine learning to collect data from the past few seasons, Field Vision Sports noted that Jefferson had the best raw Threat score that they had ever charted in 2022. They have the Vikings receiver as their No. 1 in Threat Rating (99 out of 100) heading into 2024, as well as the top Threat Rating versus zone coverage. The Vikings move Jefferson to the slot and off the line of scrimmage just enough to give him a good variety of alignments. He spent roughly 30% of his snaps in the slot last season. But he’s primarily an X-receiver who uses his route fluidity to keep his defenders off balance, then punishing them at the top of the route and catch point with his excellent hands. You could argue he’s the best pure receiver, or receiver prototype example in the game today, but I do have one more receiver above him, who I classify a bit more as an overall offensive weapon. |
|
7 |
![]() MICAH PARSONS
Dallas · EDGE/LB
|
| Parsons is a future Hall-of-Fame talent who can be used in a variety of ways, even if he is transitioning more and more to full-time pass rusher as an EDGE.
He’s been named an All-Pro in each of the last three seasons. PFF had him as the NFL’s top-graded linebacker as a rookie in 2021, and he graded out as the second best EDGE defender in pass rushing (93.7) and overall play (92.4) in each of the last two seasons. Last year, he notched a career-high 14 sacks and 19 tackles for a loss playing primarily along the line of scrimmage. He also led all EDGE defenders in pass rush win rate (35%) for the third straight year, despite being double-teamed more than anyone at his position (35%). Parsons also paced EDGE defenders in pressure rate (21.6%), pressures (99; per NFL Next Gen Stats), pass rush incompletions created (38) and in Brandon Thorn/Trench Warfare‘s in True Pressure Score and snaps per pressure (data from TruMedia and PFF). The move from linebacker to EDGE had already happened under Dan Quinn in Dallas. Per MatchQuarters and PFF, Parsons spent roughly 63% of his snaps as an off-ball LB during the first half of his rookie year before transitioning to EDGE. His coverage snaps also dipped from 295 in 2021 to 76 and 19 these past two seasons, and he spent just 5% of his snaps at off-ball LB in 2023. With Quinn in Washington, there’s talk of how he’ll be deployed with defensive coordinator Mike Zimmer. “I’m not sure he couldn’t play every position out there, to be honest with you,” Zimmer told 96.7 The Ticket. “He’s got great acceleration, great quickness, he’s extremely brilliant. He’s got power and strength. We’re trying to figure out a lot of different ways to move him. One week he might be doing this and then next week doing something else. We’re trying to get him one-on-ones as many times as possible.” I suspect Parsons will remain mostly on the edge, but having him play inside in Zimmer’s famous ‘double mug’ pressure looks in select spots is also likely. |
|
6 |
![]() T.J. WATT
Pittsburgh · EDGE
|
| Watt led the NFL in sacks (19 in 2023) for the third time in four years and earned his fourth First-team All-Pro honor in five seasons last year. He turns 30 in October, but shows no signs of slowing down. He came back from an in jury in 2022 to deliver another season-long wrecking ball performance last year.
“He can’t be labeled a high-motor guy — he’s just exceptionally hard to block, probably the hardest in the league,” a high-ranking NFL official said to ESPN. “He has technique, power, counters, violence, bend. Everything you want.” Among what I consider the “big 5” EDGE defenders (Myles Garrett, Parsons, Bosa, Crosby, Watt) right now, Watt may have the most complete game as a defender. Only he and Myles Garrett out of that group graded (PFF) in the top-1o in pass rushing (4th) and run defense (7th) among EDGE defenders last season. Watt also had four forced fumbles, three fumble recoveries, and an interception. The Steelers all-time sack leader (what a distinction, by the way) has opened up things for Alex Highsmith on the opposite edge. Pittsburgh also has Cameron Heyward back for his 14th season at age 35 in the inside at their 3-4 DE spot (4i/5-tech), and Keeanu Benton as an emerging star at nose tackle. Pittsburgh has long been a 3-4 defense that also uses a 3-4-principled Nickel defense in the 2-4-5 front. The Steelers were the only NFL team last year to use an old-school “base” defense as their most-used personnel/formation. Pittsburgh ran a 3-4 defense on 40.6% of defensive snaps, and a Nickel/Big Nickel 2-4-5 on 38.9% of snaps, per Arjun Menon’s The Scout. |
|
5 |
![]() MYLES GARRETT
Cleveland · EDGE
|
| Ranking as the top defensive player in the league here, let’s just dive right in on Myles Garrett. He was the league’s Defensive Player of the Year last year, and was named an All-Pro for the fifth time in the last six seasons.
He led all EDGE defenders in PFF grade (93.9) for the third straight year. And this was his second season in a row leading all defenders in PFF pass rush grade (94.7). A well-rounded defender, in addition to being second in pass rush win rate (30%), he was seventh among EDGE defenders in run stop win rate (31%) and sixth in PFF run defense grade (83.7). Garrett also led the NFL in interceptions created by his pass rushing (6) and quickest time to pressure (2.45 seconds), per NFL Next Gen Stats. “If you don’t double team him, he’s going to f—ing kill you,” an NFL coordinator said. The Browns run primarily a 4-down front, with a Nickel 4-2-5 look with 4-3 principles serving as their base. Veteran Za’Darius Smith rushes the passer from the opposite edge, and Davlin Tomlinson serves as a run-stuffer inside. Garrett spends some time in a Wide 9 alignment as well under defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz. Garrett’s production and career thus far are essentially what you hope for when you select a defender No. 1 overall in the draft. |
|
4 |
![]() TYREEK HILL
Miami · WR (X/Z/Slot)
|
| Tyreek Hill is my best non-QB NFL player heading into 2024 and his age-30 season. He was just rewarded another big-time contract extension by Miami, and it’s clear he’s well worth it. He’s one of the best playmakers this game has ever seen. He simply tilts fields, destroys game plans, wins at all three levels, on several different route concepts, before the catch, after the catch, etc…He’s a generational player, maybe even better that that.
“His speed changes your preparation and how you have to play defense,” an NFC executive said to ESPN. “Only a few people on earth can do that.” Hill was named First-team All-Pro for the second consecutive season, and fifth time in eight years in 2023. He posted a second-straight 1,700+ yard receiving season, and led the league in just about everything. He was first in receiving yards (1,799), receiving touchdowns (12), 20+ yard receptions (29), first downs (83), yards before contact (1,147), yards per route run, adjusted YPRR, PFF receiving grade (93.8) and overall PFF grade among WRs (93.4). It was his second year in a row leading both of those PFF marks and yards per route run. His boundary-slot snap split went from roughly 60%-40% to 64-36 in 2023. But the Dolphins still essentially move him all around, both on and off the line. To give you a better sense of the variety in which how he destroys defenses, he was fourth in yards after catch (652) and broken tackles (12) and first in yards on in-breaking routes (830) as well as receiving scores on vertical route concepts (10), per NFL Next Gen Stats. Reception Perception also charted him in the 95th percentile in success rate versus press coverage on sampled snaps. In a deeper dive with PFF, he also was first in “THREAT %” on all routes run, as well as in the slot and late in the down. He was second in THREAT % on outside snaps and in the red zone, as well as second in Field Vision Sports‘ “Threat Rating” heading into this year. Under Mike McDaniel, Hill has thrived on long crossers and overs, particularly off of play-action passing concepts, often times married with some of their zone rushes. Per Football Insights and FTN Fantasy, Tua Tagovailoa and Hill almost doubled the next closes QB-pass catcher duo in total play-action target EPA. The Dolphins also led the NFL in motion percentage last season (82.8%), per ESPN Stats & Info, which is not surprising, but they also began to implement “cheat” motion (which now may be policed by the league), often with Hill moving at the snap into a full-blown route. Hill blew away the rest of his competition in yards per route run on plays with pre or at-the-snap motion last season. In addition to cheat motion, the Dolphins ran 20.4% of their snaps in the pistol formation in 2023 per TruMedia, good for second in the NFL. The league-wide usage of pistol, although increasing, was just 5.2% last year. It’s almost unfair that a team as creative as Mike McDaniel’s Dolphins gets to use Tyreek Hill. But it sure is objectively fun to watch. |
|
3 |
![]() LAMAR JACKSON
Baltimore · QB
|
| Jackson now finds himself in rare air as a two-time NFL MVP and First-team All-Pro quarterback. He made the switch from bulky, condensed shotgun formations under Greg Roman to shotgun-spread, pistol and under-center looks in new offensive coordinator Todd Monken’s system, and in turn, matured greatly as a passer.
Jackson posted the highest PFF grade of any QB on throws going 10-19 passing yards. He also posted career-highs in pass attempts (457), completion percentage (67.2%), yards per attempt (8.0) and PFF grade (90.4). Jackson also threw just seven interceptions and was fourth in Total QBR (64.7). “How he came in, with everything stuck to that stigma as a runner, that sticks with you as a pro until you prove them wrong,” an NFC executive said to ESPN. “That’s not fair but that’s the way it’s been with him. There wasn’t any doubt who the best player in the league was last year. So, it’s long been time to put that to rest.” Make no mistake, Jackson still thrived as a runner. He was second among QBs in PFF run grade (90.8), and had 148 rush attempts, which is good for third-most in his six-year career. His 821 rush yards and five rushing scores give him 5,258 rush yards and 29 rushing TDs for his career. Only Patrick Mahomes (.774) and Tom Brady (.754) have a better regular season winning percentage (min. 50 starts) than Jackson (58-19, 75.3) in the modern era. But Baltimore is yet to get over the hump in the playoffs. Jackson has a 2-4 record in the postseason, averaging 10.5 points per game in his losses, which seem to follow a similar blue print. While watching them lose the AFC title game to Kansas City at home, it’s worth wondering if Baltimore shouldn’t have fully abandoned some of the things that made them great in the Greg Roman years. It’s harder to drop-back pass all game deep in the playoffs against better teams. Thankfully for Jackson, Baltimore seems to be recalibrating with the signing of Derrick Henry this offseason. Henry has flourished despite seeing more stacked boxes lately than any rusher. Last season, Henry had a 88.4% play rate versus 7+man boxes while in Tennessee, and Jackson in Baltimore ranked first in EPA/play and success rate versus 7+man boxes, per Sharp Football Analysis. The Ravens are one of the smartest organizations in the league, so as long as Jackson stays healthy, the franchise-QB marriage here should keep Baltimore in the mix for years to come. |
|
2 |
![]() JOSH ALLEN
Buffalo · QB
|
| Allen’s herculean, 1980s John Elway-esque effort to lead the Bills to stardom has yet to lead Buffalo to the Super Bowl, but four straight AFC East titles will do in showcasing his level to elevate a franchise that starved for an era like this since the early 1990s.
Allen led the NFL in total yards, total touchdowns (44) and PFF grade (92.1) last season. He was second among QBs in PFF passing grade (88.2) and EPA/play and had the lowest sack rate when pressured. He was also first among QBs in PFF rush grade (91.6) and Rush EPA and ran for a whopping 15 (!) touchdowns. To give a sense of his style of play, he leads the NFL in both total touchdowns (173) and interceptions (47) since 2020. But I’d argue, despite 18 interceptions last season, he’s made improvements as a passer in recent years that put him up there as one of the best pro passing development stories we’ve ever seen. There are two major factors that will come into play with Allen and the passing offense this year. One is offensive coordinator Joe Brady getting his first full season to conceptually lead the unit. When Brady took over after Week 10 last year, Buffalo ranked second in EPA/play on play-action passing the rest of the way, per NFL Next Gen Stats. The Bills affectively ran the ball more and began to operate more under center. Additionally, the departure of Stefon Diggs and Gabe Davis, along the current Bills pass-catching group, suggest that there will be a lot of passing work done underneath and in the shallow/intermediate part of the field despite Allen ranking in the top five in aDot in each of the last two seasons. Per Sports Info Solutions, on quick-game drop-backs and 3 or 5-step dropbacks out of shotgun (no play-action/RPO; min. 200 pass attempts), Allen was first among all QBs in completion percentage (71.1%) and catchable ball rate (>90%), and second in success rate. He was also first in PFF short passing grade on throws for under 10 yards. Along with running back James Cook and flex-TE Dalton Kincaid, the top receivers are projected to be rookie ‘power’ slot Keon Colemon, Curtis Samuel and Khalil Shakir. Marques-Valdez Scantling was signed to perhaps fill the same role he did in KC as a low-target downfield X-receiver to keep defenses honest. With Allen steering the ship, they should be able to navigate the post-Diggs era with confidence. |
|
1 |
![]() PATRICK MAHOMES
Kansas City · QB
|
| Mahomes’ six-year start to his NFL career as a starting QB is perhaps the best intro of any passer in this league’s history. He capped off his third Super Bowl win in four appearances (Tom Brady’s fourth Super Bowl appearance came in his seventh starting season) to add to a resume that already includes two NFL MVP awards, and the best winning percentage (regular season + postseason, min. 100 starts) of all-time (89-25, 78.1%).
What’s so impressive about Mahomes’ continued greatness is how different their passing game has been in the last two Super Bowl wins compared to the first. They essentially went from a downfield passing attack with Tyreek Hill to an underneath/YAC-oriented offense in 2022 and 2023. A year after throwing 31 of his 41 TD passes to running backs and tight ends, 14 of his 28 TD passes in 2023 went to RBs/TEs. The Chiefs also heavily leaned on multi-TE sets yet again. They had the most passing attempts with three tight ends on the field (46) in the league, and led the NFL in dropbacks with pre-snap motion, per Sports Info Solutions. Furthermore, after already experiencing a declining aDOT from 2021 to 2022, Mahomes ranked 31st out of 32 qualifying quarterbacks in average air yards per pass attempt (6.2) in 2023. Mahomes did this all mostly versus two-high safety defenses designed to keep him operating underneath. They saw a league-high 455 two-high snaps in 2023, and the Chiefs battled back by running the ball and quickly getting the ball out underneath, allowing their playmakers to create yardage. Mahomes threw for 12 touchdown passes and zero interceptions on his 217 “quick-game attempts,” that came with a zero or one-step drop in the pocket, and he led the NFL in percentage of passing yards after the catch, per Fantasy Points Data. So when looking at his career-low QBR and career-high interception rates from last year, it’s contextually irrelevant to his play in the postseason, in nut-crunching time. I’m not sure all fans know just how hard it is to operate this type of short-game offense versus a top defense in conference title games and Super Bowls (think: Brady vs Legion of Boom Seattle in Super Bowl 49). As we saw with Baltimore, it’s harder to pass versus tough defenses late in January, when sphincters tighten and every passing window is smaller. As for the help around Mahomes — Travis Kelce is still great, but aging. Rashee Rice (suspension incoming?) has brought more upside to the JuJu Smith-Schuster underneath/YAC role. Hollywood Brown may miss the start of the season but when healthy is a downfield threat that should open the Chiefs’ passing game up a bit, and rookie first-round pick Xavier Worthy should help on all three levels of the field. Although I still expect the Chiefs to rely on underneath concepts such as ‘mesh,’ I believe they are trying to find a middle ground, or balance, to their underneath attack by attempting to add elements for a downfield game. It’s a best-of-both-worlds scenario. This team and franchise is in a great spot. Will we see the first-ever NFL three-peat? Enjoy the season, everyone. |
|






































































































Talanoa Hufanga— S, San Francisco 49ers (Last year: NR)
Tariq Woolen — CB, Seattle Seahawks (Last year: NR)
Dalvin Cook – RB, New York Jets (Last year: 62)
Rhamondre Stevenson — RB, New England Patriots (Last year: NR)
Michael Onwenu — OG, New England Patriots (Last year: NR)
Dallas Goedert — TE, Philadelphia Eagles (Last year: NR)
Travis Etienne Jr. — RB, Jacksonville Jaguars (Last year: NR)
Tee Higgins – WR (X), Cincinnati Bengals (Last year: NR)
Shaquille Leonard – LB, Indianapolis Colts (Last year: 30)
Jaelen Phillips — EDGE, Miami Dolphins (Last year: NR)
Haason Reddick — EDGE, Philadelphia Eagles (Last year: NR)
Stephon Gilmore – CB, Dallas Cowboys (Last year: 80)
D.J. Reader – DI, Cincinnati Bengals (Last year: NR)
Josh Jacobs — RB, Las Vegas Raiders (Last year: NR)
Kevin Byard – S, Tennessee Titans (Last year: 40)
Matthew Judon — EDGE, New England Patriots (Last year: 99)
Justin Simmons – S, Denver Broncos (Last year: 70)
Deebo Samuel – WR (Gadget/RB), San Francisco 49ers (Last year: 31)
Jaycee Horn – CB, Carolina Panthers (Last year: NR)
Jonathan Allen – DI, Washington Commanders (Last year: 58)
Marlon Humphrey – CB, Baltimore Ravens (Last year: 50)
Terry McLaurin – WR (X), Washington Commanders (Last year: 86)
Derwin James – S, Los Angeles Chargers (Last year: 54)
Bobby Wagner – LB, Seattle Seahawks (Last year: 61)
Cameron Heyward – DI, Pittsburgh Steelers (Last year: 49)
Joey Bosa – EDGE, Los Angeles Chargers (Last year: 19)
Jason Kelce – C, Philadelphia Eagles (Last year: NR, ‘Next’ 25)
Jaire Alexander – CB, Green Bay Packers (Last year: 48)
Nick Chubb – RB, Cleveland Browns (Last year: 44)
Cooper Kupp – WR (Z/Slot), Los Angeles Rams (Last year: 13)
Aaron Donald – DI, Los Angeles Rams (Last year: 1)





